Andy Carroll In Danger Yo !

I'd be extremely disappointed if were to sell Carroll now. To be completely honest I'd lose some of the faith I've so far mustered with regards to Rodgers.

Carroll can be a beast of a player for most teams imo. He's far better on the ball that many gives him credit for and he can score goals from outside the box, inside the box and in the air. Like from everywhere. Give the lad some faith and he'll deliver.

There's not ONE good reason to sell him at this moment in time especially with regards to 're-sell' value being around 1/2 - 1/3 of what we initially paid. We need to stop all this fucking around with players going in and out all the time (and managers too) and to be honest when posters like Ryan etc. are talking about 'he should've proved himself in 18 months' it makes me wonder why the likes of Lucas; Skrtel etc. were all given such a leach from the same posters despite looking well below par for several Season.

Fair enough if you don't like the cut of his jib but really it would make little sense to ship him of now, after a decent Euros and more than encouraging end of last Season.

Well you could make the argument that it might not be the worst time to sell him after a decent little spell of form, especially if we're short of money and the manager doesn't see a major role in his plans for him. In that case he's unlikely to play well or often enough for his value to really appreciate and all the while you're holding him in place of a player the manager really does want.

Lucas was horrendously mediocre for several Seasons Mark, scapegoat of the Season for several Seasons even, and yet posters on here defended him. Right or wrong. Skrtel imo wasn't cut for the standard either for several Seasons but both have improved no end. We'll never agree on this matter mind.

Anyways I don't want us to sell Carroll. Period. If we do I hope Rodgers has at least seen him up close at training before deciding.

View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWaLxFIVX1s

Carroll obviously isn't worth what ever money we splashed for him. At this point in time.

However the question is, do you believe he could indeed prove value for us in the future. In my opinion there is no doubt that he could turn out to the be £30M striker we all hoped for. Even in a possession-based team, perhaps even more so.

I don't care about fees, salaries etc., all I care for is us to go forward and in my opinion Carroll could be a vital cog in that forward-going vessel. I didn't mean to disrespect any player in the team just irritated me a little to see posters wanting Carroll out.

I can actually see the case for loaning him out, too. If he went somewhere more suitable he might well add £5m+ to his value, although obviously it's a trade-off against having the money to spend now.

I agree with our Danish lad, we shouldnt sell Carroll...
Granted, he was never worth 35M but how much are we going to recoup? 15-20m tops...to buy who?
The lad will become a decent dtriker, the signs are here.
Its a no for me

If Agger's legs, back and forehead had been a little less broken/fractured/swollen he had played Mark, I bet he had.

*That's me trying to make fun of a subject I can't be bothered to dig into again.

WE AGREE TO DISAGREE ON THE OMEN THAT IS SKRTEL!

NEXT BEER IS ON ME!

I don't think we have ever agreed on anything before apart from cheering Liverpool on?!

I will now pop open a chilled beer out of sheer glee

*CHEERS 6CM*

Well I suppose that's where people will always differ. Imo there's no doubt that he *won't* turn into a £30m player.

As for who we'd spend the money on - well, Borini, for a start. If Rodgers sees him as a better option then in effect we're better off even if we only got enough for Carroll to cover that fee.

Ha! I dont know... I dont agree about Skrtel though
Skol!

Sam Delaney ‏@DelaneyMan
Tony Blair AND Sam Allardyce are at this party I'm at. Sam reckons we've got half a chance for A Carroll. Tony, no opinion on the matter.

Telegraph saying Villa, Fulham and West Ham are interested

How about a longshot on Mourinho seeing him as a future Drogba type for Madrid?

Is this a woosh

If we sell Carroll we'll probably spend wisely and buy Bendtner. Is that what you guys want?

IS IT?

To be fair he looked decent at the Euro's, he is young

For £5-7 million he could be an option

View: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkKWcRZGCbY&feature=related

Sounds like we have sounded him out to several clubs. He's finished.

I think its a massive mistake, but Rodgers need to do whats right for his set up.
His problem at Reading was that he changed everything at once. Hopefully he's learned from that experience.