POTY
- Thread starter the count
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
Voting was in January wasn't it? Gomez was main right back up til then.
Next year you'd fancy Trent to be nominated
I still think it's laughable Kane's nominated. Surely it should be one or the other?
And speaks volumes about sessegnon
That's fair enough. I know Rashford has hardly started since the arrival of Sanchez.
Perhaps he was more prominent for them in the first half of the season.
Even then, I don't think rashford was that instrumental... Must be fuck all youth
What’s the cut off age for young player of the year? 28?
KDB will win poty and Kane the ypoty
Harry Kane was born in July 1993. He'll be 25 in July.
YPOTY?! FFS!
There should be an old player of the year for over 32s.
Kane would be a shoe in
Are you trying to whoosh me?
Just saw James Maddison's stats (14 goals 8 assists in 39 app). Wouldn't it have been better to reward/acknowledge his efforts instead of those 2 turning 25 in a couple of month's time?
Last edited:
Sure. I believe 21 should probably be the right age for young player....
Yeah
Can't agree with that
2 have been instrumental in winning a title, the other instrumental in united not being a laughing stock this year.
Instrumental doesn't mean better than Firmino (and that's, figures courtesy of the BBC I think it was on YouTube, in a £850m team vs. a £470m team). Firmino's stats on everything from scoring, assists, tackles, kms run, weetabix eaten, teeth whitening used .. in fact everything ... are simply some of the best in Europe never mind England. As a forward his stats rival theirs as midfielders, whilst being superior in both defence and attack. Silva, Sane and De Gea have had good seasons but they've done nothing that exceptional, IMO of course, to put them ahead of Firmino. They've had decent seasons but POTY ? Just padding.
Last edited:
De Gea is probably The Outstanding Player of The Year. The two others I might agree With.
You're comparing someone at the top of a spear against 2 wingers.
Tackles from a striker are meaningless really for most teams.
And, as is always the danger when looking solely at stats, you're taking away the fantastic work Silva and sane do
Firmino has had a good season for a striker. Sane and Silva have been instrumental in a dominant city side.
They've been better (in a different way), than bobby
Tackles from a striker are meaningless really for most teams.
And, as is always the danger when looking solely at stats, you're taking away the fantastic work Silva and sane do
Firmino has had a good season for a striker. Sane and Silva have been instrumental in a dominant city side.
They've been better (in a different way), than bobby
Bobby being in poty would be more blatant padding than those 2 IMO
There's been some brilliant players in this league that are being overlooked
For sheer comparison between points won with/without a player, lascelles deserves a nomination
Nick pope should be there as much as de gea
The whole poty is top 4 pandering.
There's been some brilliant players in this league that are being overlooked
For sheer comparison between points won with/without a player, lascelles deserves a nomination
Nick pope should be there as much as de gea
The whole poty is top 4 pandering.
Voting was in January? So it's over the whole of 2017? If it's voting for the season 17/18 in January then it's a farce.
Why do they present nominees now if they already voted for them 3 months ago?
No way should Bobby be near POTY
Arguing the merits of the City players or De Gea I understand. Saying he shouldn’t be near POTY is stupid. Of course he should. He’s been phenomenal.
- Status
