• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Transfer window nearly upon us

Status
Not open for further replies.
The height factor can be exaggerated.

Of course at 1.84 he isn't exactly a giant, but he isn't a midget either.

There's loads of tall keepers going around like Steklenberg, Al Habsi, Huerelho Gomes for example ... have the height but not the technical & mental aspects to be come truly top class keepers.

Same goes for strikers ... Peter Crouch is a giant and yet can't head the ball with any conviction & very rarely wins headers in the box ... then you look at someone like Tim Cahill who at 178cm height out jumped the tallest of defenders and scored ridiculous amounts of headers. And ppl would have said no way can he get on the end of a cross he is too small.

FYI - Valdes 183cm, Cassilas 185cm.


5' 11" is 1.80 not 1.84 (I know because it's my height) ! I don't think Casillas is 185cm, I think he's 180cm too but I've read conflicting gen on that that.

Cahill was all about timing not the height of his jumps. Though he could certainly jump higher than your average player. Crouchy wins a lot of headers in the box - don't know where you get the idea he doesn't from !

Of course height doesn't = a good keeper. But I honestly think it is a pre-requisite for a really top keeper in the modern game. Certainly in the more physical leagues of the PL & Bundesliga. You have given a list of tall keepers who aren't at the top .. how about a list of shorter keepers (180cms or under) that are ? That is a far greater ask, for a very good reason.
 
Actually just checked on the official Aussie National Team site - they give his height as 184cms and I guess they should know !

1.84 is just under 6' 1". So not a midget after all. I'd still prefer a taller keeper, everything else being equal, though.
 
I think arm length is more telling than height. Keepers like Courtois who are pretty lanky are at an advantage.
 
I can recall someone showing this to me and being mostly true
Mostly true, but there are definitely exceptions, usually among athletes.

Think NFL Wide Receivers or NBA Players. Kevin Durant wouldn't be nearly as good if he wasn't so crazy lanky. Same goes for keepers I feel.
 
Mostly true, but there are definitely exceptions, usually among athletes.

Think NFL Wide Receivers or NBA Players. Kevin Durant wouldn't be nearly as good if he wasn't so crazy lanky. Same goes for keepers I feel.


Yea one of my mates is really lanky didn't apply exactly to him.
 
Isn't arm span, and hence length, the same as your height?

Or am I taking DaVinci a little too literally...

Generally.

But in the NBA, having a wingspan which is the same as your height is generally considered a poor wingspan. Most of the top players have wingspans that are a good 4-5 inches more than their height.

Lebron is 6'8" with a 7'0" wingspan. Kobe is 6'6" with a 6'11 wingspan. Charles Barkley another - considered massively undersized for the power forward (he was about 6'4"), but he was said to have a 7'0" wingspan.

Kawhi Leonard is the best example today of a freakish wingspan - 6'7" height, 7'3" wingspan.

Draftexpress has a list of average height/wingspan ratios of all players in its database - and you'll find wingspan is generally height + 2/3 inches: http://www.draftexpress.com/nba-pre-draft-measurements/?page=averages&year=All
 
So we've recalled Ibe, why? He hasn't exactly been setting the championship alight has he? Hes a better option up front the Borini I suppose.
 
So we've recalled Ibe, why? He hasn't exactly been setting the championship alight has he? Hes a better option up front the Borini I suppose.
He's been doing quite well in the championship
 
Generally.

But in the NBA, having a wingspan which is the same as your height is generally considered a poor wingspan. Most of the top players have wingspans that are a good 4-5 inches more than their height.

Lebron is 6'8" with a 7'0" wingspan. Kobe is 6'6" with a 6'11 wingspan. Charles Barkley another - considered massively undersized for the power forward (he was about 6'4"), but he was said to have a 7'0" wingspan.

Kawhi Leonard is the best example today of a freakish wingspan - 6'7" height, 7'3" wingspan.

Draftexpress has a list of average height/wingspan ratios of all players in its database - and you'll find wingspan is generally height + 2/3 inches: http://www.draftexpress.com/nba-pre-draft-measurements/?page=averages&year=All

"My daughter's boyfriends? I figure if I kill the first one, word'll get out." [Charles Barkley]
 
Actually just checked on the official Aussie National Team site - they give his height as 184cms and I guess they should know !

1.84 is just under 6' 1". So not a midget after all. I'd still prefer a taller keeper, everything else being equal, though.

There seem to be 3 different opinions about his height on the interweb.
Either way, a bit short arsed for a gk... :)
 
Isn't arm span, and hence length, the same as your height?

Or am I taking DaVinci a little too literally...

It's generally close to the same but there are plenty of top athletes (NBA basketball players for example) that have much longer wingspans than their height.

For example Anthony Davis is 6' 9.25" without shoes but his wingspan is 7' 5.5"

DeAndre Jordan is 6' 9.75" but his wingspan is 7' 6"

Hassan Whiteside of the Heat is 6' 10.5" but his wingspan is 7' 7" !!!

There are even some shorter guys with crazy long wingspan.

Dwyane Wade for example is 6' 3.75" but his wingspan is 6' 10.75" which is crazy to me.
 
Pffff. I'm 5'11" with a wingspan of 6' 6". That gives me +7" which as % of my height is 9.86%. Waaay more than Wade whose +7" is only 9.24% of his height and as for that mofo Whiteside his +8.5" is only a tad more at 10.3% of his height. Fecking NBA pussies.

I do have to have custom made long-sleeve shirts though :(
 
Pffff. I'm 5'11" with a wingspan of 6' 6". That gives me +7" which as % of my height is 9.86%. Waaay more than Wade whose +7" is only 9.24% of his height and as for that mofo Whiteside his +8.5" is only a tad more at 10.3% of his height. Fecking NBA pussies.

I do have to have custom made long-sleeve shirts though :(

Is this you in the middle, Froggy?


imageslong-arms-700x525_small.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom