• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Everybody's got a price?

Forums Unread posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
SummerOnions

SummerOnions

Let's Push Things Forward
Moderator
Take the key members of the squad and state how much you'd begrudgingly accept for each of them if they had to go.

Reina -
Carra -
Agger -
Johnson -
Lucas -
Meireles -
Gerrard -
Suarez -
Kuyt -
Carroll -
 
[quote author=SummerOnions link=topic=45833.msg1353911#msg1353911 date=1308830145]
Take the key members of the squad and state how much you'd begrudgingly accept for each of them if they had to go.

Reina - 30m
Carra - No amount of money.
Agger - 8m
Johnson - 20m
Lucas - 25m
Meireles - Wouldnt sell
Gerrard - No amount of money
Suarez - No amount of money
Kuyt - No amount of money
Carroll -
[/quote]
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=45833.msg1353915#msg1353915 date=1308830440]
[quote author=SummerOnions link=topic=45833.msg1353911#msg1353911 date=1308830145]
Take the key members of the squad and state how much you'd begrudgingly accept for each of them if they had to go.

Reina - 30m
Carra - No amount of money.
Agger - 8m
Johnson - 20m
Lucas - 25m
Meireles - Wouldnt sell
Gerrard - No amount of money
Suarez - No amount of money
Kuyt - No amount of money
Carroll -
[/quote]
[/quote]

This will do.
 
Reina - tilted 8
Carra - tilted 8
Agger - tilted 8 (for sentimental reasons mostly)
Johnson - £20M
Lucas - £10M
Meireles - £8M
Gerrard - tilted 8
Suarez - tilted 8
Kuyt - £12M
Carroll - tilted 8
 
The only ones I wouldn't sell under any circumstances right now would be Carragher and Gerrard, as they are worth more to us than we would ever get

I am tempted to put Suarez in that category too, simply because we don't have much else in the way of creative attacking flair right now.

For the others I'd say:
Reina - 30m
Johnson - 25m
Lucas - 15m
Meireles - 20m
Kuyt - 15m
Carroll - £55

Not sure what Agger is doing there really. The others are our star players. We should be looking to get rid of that crock anyway.
 
Reina - £50m
Carra - £25m
Agger - £12m
Johnson - £25M
Lucas - £16M
Meireles - £16M
Gerrard - £45m
Suarez - £65m
Kuyt - £18m
Carroll - £45m
 
Reina - 35M
Carra - 15M
Agger - 10M
Johnson - 20M
Lucas - 10M
Meireles - 20M
Gerrard - 35M
Suarez - 60M
Kuyt - 15M
Carroll - 25M
 
Reina - 35
Carra - 20
Agger - 15
Johnson - 25
Lucas - 15
Meireles - 20
Gerrard - 30
Suarez - 60
Kuyt - 15
Carroll - 50
 
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353940#msg1353940 date=1308832222]
The only ones I wouldn't sell under any circumstances right now would be Carragher and Gerrard, as they are worth more to us than we would ever get

I am tempted to put Suarez in that category too, simply because we don't have much else in the way of creative attacking flair right now.

For the others I'd say:
Reina - 30m
Johnson - 25m
Lucas - 15m
Meireles - 20m
Kuyt - 15m
Carroll - £55

Not sure what Agger is doing there really. The others are our star players. We should be looking to get rid of that crock anyway.

[/quote]
*This post has failed*
 
Failed to do what? Give my opinion? 'Fraid it hasn't. Sorry that you disagree with it though.
 
Reina - £30M
Carra - Nah
Agger - £11M
Johnson - £18M
Lucas - £10M
Meireles - £18M
Gerrard - Nah
Suarez - £50M
Kuyt - £18M
Carroll -£25M
 
A bit to surprised to see the general valuation of Raul on here. Don't get me wrong he scored some belters for us and was one of our better players last Season but £20M?

I can't see that to be honest.

£10M at most if we're looking to sell is my bet.
 
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353952#msg1353952 date=1308833688]
Failed to do what? Give my opinion? 'Fraid it hasn't. Sorry that you disagree with it though.
[/quote]
I was merely trying to make a witty remark.

I failed too.
 
I don't think it's the valuation of the player, it's the price you would be happy to let them go for. Hence your tilted 8 for Agger.
 
Reina - Very reluctant to sell, would need to have an amazing replacement lined up £25 - 35 million + amazing player + Reina wanting to leave + us needing to sell
Carra - n\a
Agger -£12 Million
Johnson - £20 Million
Lucas - £10 Million
Meireles - £12 Million
Gerrard - n\a
Suarez - n\a
Kuyt - £12 Million
Carroll - £30 Million, but I'm very worried that we will be seeking £15 next season...
 
[quote author=KHL link=topic=45833.msg1353956#msg1353956 date=1308833837]
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353952#msg1353952 date=1308833688]
Failed to do what? Give my opinion? 'Fraid it hasn't. Sorry that you disagree with it though.
[/quote]
I was merely trying to make a witty remark.

I failed too.
[/quote]

Sorry mate. Am a bit grumpy today.
 
Another thing. There's no money in the world that'll take away either Suarez or Carroll at this point in time with us building a new team/squad. They've played like what, four months, and we've paid gazillions for both of them.

Let me rephrase; Did somone offer us the moon and half of Asia we'd probably sell but that's not likely why their inclusion seems somewhat unneccessary.

Should Real offer silly £50M we'd still turn them down as you can't build a succesful team by selling and buying key-players on a monthly basis.
 
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353962#msg1353962 date=1308833909]
[quote author=KHL link=topic=45833.msg1353956#msg1353956 date=1308833837]
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353952#msg1353952 date=1308833688]
Failed to do what? Give my opinion? 'Fraid it hasn't. Sorry that you disagree with it though.
[/quote]
I was merely trying to make a witty remark.

I failed too.
[/quote]

Sorry mate. Am a bit grumpy today.
[/quote]

You mean 'mental' 😉
 
[quote author=Squiggles link=topic=45833.msg1353965#msg1353965 date=1308834105]
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353962#msg1353962 date=1308833909]
[quote author=KHL link=topic=45833.msg1353956#msg1353956 date=1308833837]
[quote author=Richey link=topic=45833.msg1353952#msg1353952 date=1308833688]
Failed to do what? Give my opinion? 'Fraid it hasn't. Sorry that you disagree with it though.
[/quote]
I was merely trying to make a witty remark.

I failed too.
[/quote]

Sorry mate. Am a bit grumpy today.
[/quote]

You mean 'mental' 😉
[/quote]

Haha. Yeah, that too!!
 
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=45833.msg1353958#msg1353958 date=1308833849]
I don't think it's the valuation of the player, it's the price you would be happy to let them go for. Hence your tilted 8 for Agger.
[/quote]
Yes. I meant that. Scouts honor.

If we'd fetch around £10M for Raul - with Henderson already beeing brought in and Spearing stepping up - we could use that money for a RM/Winger type like Mata, a position we are soooooo much more in need of at this point in time.

Raul has been a good player but I'm just not sure about his future here to be honest. He's not a winger in a 4-3-3 and I doubt he's going to bench either of Gerrard, Henderson or Lucas. With Spearing and to some extent Shelvey in the shades, and perhaps even Adam coming in he could end up somewhat surplus to requirements.
 
I wouldn't swap a one whole Raul Meireles for one half of a Stuart Downing.
 
[quote author=KHL link=topic=45833.msg1353964#msg1353964 date=1308834097]
Another thing. There's no money in the world that'll take away either Suarez or Carroll at this point in time with us building a new team/squad. They've played like what, four months, and we've paid gazillions for both of them.

Let me rephrase; Did somone offer us the moon and half of Asia we'd probably sell but that's not likely why their inclusion seems somewhat unneccessary.

Should Real offer silly £50M we'd still turn them down as you can't build a succesful team by selling and buying key-players on a monthly basis.
[/quote]

I would sell Carroll for 35M in a heartbeat and buy Augero instead. Much more "proven" and much more suitable for our style of play.
 
Reina - 35m
Carra - would not sell
Agger - 9m
Johnson -25m
Lucas -25m
Meireles -22m
Gerrard - would not sell
Suarez -70m
Kuyt - 17m
Carroll -45m
 
Reina - X
Carra - £10mil
Agger - £10mil
Johnson - £15mil
Lucas - £10mil
Meireles - £25mil
Gerrard - £20mil
Suarez - x
Kuyt - £10mil
Carroll - x
 
I see you'd sell Gerrard for less money than Raul Kenny.


































[size=44pt]WHAT![/size]
 
[quote author=Kenny4PM link=topic=45833.msg1354013#msg1354013 date=1308837416]
He's 31 now mate
[/quote]
Raul's not far off and isn't anywhere near Gerrard's levels.

I'M PUZZLED.
 
[quote author=KHL link=topic=45833.msg1354017#msg1354017 date=1308837539]
[quote author=Kenny4PM link=topic=45833.msg1354013#msg1354013 date=1308837416]
He's 31 now mate
[/quote]
Raul's not far off and isn't anywhere near Gerrard's levels.

I'M PUZZLED.
[/quote]

He's 3 years younger + he was a few levels above Stevie last season.

I'm not sure "i" could sell him tbh, but i'd certainly understand if the club did if a good offer came in.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom