• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The old band is back together

The only two we HAVE to replace from the current squad paid very little part of the season - it in Thiago’s case no part.

There’s no major rebuild needed here - a couple of top signings and if Slot is as good a manager as his reputation suggests, there’s no reason momentum should stop.

Momentum stops the minute we start selling a stack of players and then have to bring in and integrate a pile of new players.

I’m pretty sure Edwards will be smart enough to see that.

True. But over the next few years, we will know how good Edwards and company are. Our transfer successes have slipped since they disbanded; they were not that great before Klopp arrived, either. There is also the possibility that the period of us being relentlessly good was an anomaly - a perfect storm of players rejecting us (Gotze, Brandt), identifying superb backups (Mane, Salah), and Klopp's coaching elevating everyone to a whole new level - that will never be repeated again.
 
True. But over the next few years, we will know how good Edwards and company are. Our transfer successes have slipped since they disbanded; they were not that great before Klopp arrived, either. There is also the possibility that the period of us being relentlessly good was an anomaly - a perfect storm of players rejecting us (Gotze, Brandt), identifying superb backups (Mane, Salah), and Klopp's coaching elevating everyone to a whole new level - that will never be repeated again.
Pretty much covered it, all eyes on Edwards and gang. Pressure will be all on them this time unlike before where their initial bad transfers were overriden by the number of succesfull ones post them. Can’t wait to. see the summer activity.
 
True. But over the next few years, we will know how good Edwards and company are. Our transfer successes have slipped since they disbanded; they were not that great before Klopp arrived, either. There is also the possibility that the period of us being relentlessly good was an anomaly - a perfect storm of players rejecting us (Gotze, Brandt), identifying superb backups (Mane, Salah), and Klopp's coaching elevating everyone to a whole new level - that will never be repeated again.

I agree - this is where we find out if they ARE actually the smartest guys in the room or a bunch of bullshit artists with a nifty PowerPoint presentation.
 
When we were really good, everyone decided that everything about us was the best in the world, rather than us having a team that made everyone look as good as they could. That is exactly as it should be, from the players right on up, but it's not conclusive.

The management team for the most part can't have been that successful post Liverpool, because they've all agreed to come back, and Michael Edwards was consulting previously, which is where, if you do it right, you make far more money for less work.

The idea that it's managing in aggregate is true, but it's just another way of saying that we didn't want to hire a manager we couldn't control, and we had to punt on a coach that we can instead, as there were no great options. This isn't some new idea, it's just preparing for a more likely failure. Slot is almost certainly going to be worse at klopp at getting more out of the players he has, which is just as important as getting the team getting in the transfers right, which nobody does all the time.

The inarguable thing that this team did well before was negotiations. Yay.
 
Back
Top Bottom