• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Liverpool FC: 4 Players Leaving in Summer and Possible Replacements

Status
Not open for further replies.

RolandG

King Ding-A-Ling
Member
- JAI JOSHI (Contributor) on February 19, 2011

?

"King" Kenny Dalglish: Needs 3-4 marquee players to complete the Reds Revolution
Alex Livesey/Getty Images

Forget about the tabloids and the pundits of world football who suggest that Liverpool now have a squad (not just a team) to challenge for the fourth spot of Champions League this year and the Premier League title next year.

As much as Fernando Torres' departure has strengthened the Reds' forward line with more attacking flair, they still have players who are just not up to the mark to be a part of Liverpool's revolution under King Kenny Dalglish.

The arrival of injured Englishman Andy Carroll and the sensational and tricky Luis Suarez needs to be backed up with a quality replacement of at leastthree players if Liverpoolreally wants to challenge for anything next season.

The following four lightweight players need to be shown the exit door of Anfield to ensure a better future for the club. Not because these players are not stars, but because some of them are past their best days, and some of them will not get enough time to become best.

Their possible replacements are also suggested here, and feel free to add your own if you differ from my choices.

1. Joe "£90,000 a Week" Cole

?

JC: Would John Henry have permitted the £90000/week free signing?
Clint Hughes/Getty Images

First of all, the ex-Chelsea midfielder would have hoped for a better start at Liverpool following his red card in the opening game against Arsenal at Anfield.

Since then, Joe Cole has never truly recovered.

He has started 11 games in the league and managed to score one goal--yes one goal.

Arriving on Merseyside on a free transfer, Cole is costing £90,000 a week in wages. In other words, nearly £5 million a year.

That doesn't make it a free transfer now, does it?

Cole is no doubt a class act. Or rather, he was a class act. On occasions, he showed his ability to play behind the striker "in the hole" and showed some glimpses of his past talents. But the problem with Cole is that many believe he has past his best days now.

The Liverpool No. 10, even when fit, has failed to impress Kenny Dalglish. Dalglish has never started Cole in any Premier League games, and he seems to be sticking with his ideas for the rest of the season too.

This hints that Dalglish does not really believe in this player's ability anymore.

So much was expected from this Londonerupon arriving at Liverpool this last summer, but he has failed to impress anyone since then.

Joe Cole would be a stumbling blockfor Liverpool's revolution of next generation football, which includes the "young and exciting" philosophy.

One can not help but think had John Henry and FSG been in charge at that time, would Joe Cole be playing at Liverpool for this hefty weekly wages for a 30-year-old?

Possible Replacements:

1. Keisuke Honda:

The 24-year-old Japanese superstar is perhaps the best option as he is available in summer, and£12-14 million should be able to bring him to Anfield. The Blue Samurai can play on both wings, as well as behind thestriker, thus making him a more versatile player then the other replacement below.

However,getting the work permit to play in England will be a massive obstacle to lure the CSKA-Moscow midfielder.

2. AshleyYoung:

He is the most coveted of players. Ashley Youngwas rumoured to be on his way out in Januarytransfer window only for Aston Villa to hold on to him for now, at least.

The25-year-old could be the answer to Liverpool's left wing problems.

A hefty £20 million price tag will make him doubtful for any futureat Anfield if FSG-Liverpool's owners decide to opt for a much cheaper option.

2. Maxi "Sitter-Missing" Rodriguez

?

Maxi: The only "glorious" Liverpool moment? (Goal V Bolton)
Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

I have now lost the count of the Argentine's missed sitters two or three yards from goal.

If there is anyone who needs to be shown the door at Liverpool first, it's Maxi Rodriguez.

Although the player has scored more than Joe Cole--four goals in league so far--he could have easily scored at least that many more.

Some may suggest he has justified his price tag of free with a few good performances, but he still occupies one of the troublesome places on the field where Liverpool lacks pace, strength and goals.

After the match against Manchester United, one football analyst clearly summed upMaxi's Liverpool career in these words:

"Maxi Rodriquez: I had forgotten he was even playing when he was subbed. Hard to believe this is a man with 41 caps for Argentina. What was he supposed to be doing? He certainly offered nothing going forwards, nor going backwards for that matter. May actually have spent the whole game hiding in an underground burrow with some rabbits."

Liverpool cannot afford to keep players of his quality with the likes of Steven Gerrard, Pepe Reina, Raul Meireles, Andy Carroll and Luis Suarez.

When the club has players like the above, they need to be backed up with players of same, if not more, quality in other areas. And having Maxi Rodriguez on either wing isanother step backwards for the Red revolution.

Possible Replacements:

1.Eden Hazard:

One of the most technically gifted right wingers in Europe is said to be out of his current club Lilie during the next summer transfer window.

Damien Comolli--the former Director of Football at the French side Lilie--is said to be the admirer of Hazard and Dimitri Payet.

The 20-year-old attacking midfielder is perhaps one of the most expensive prospects in world football. He is thought to be carrying a price tag of £20 million, a high flying price.

Comolli is thought to be bringing at least one of the star duo--Hazard and Payet--to successfully start his role at Anfield.

2.Charles N'Zogbia:

Although not a natural right winger, N'Zogbia can play at right wing when it's required. One of the beauties of his game at Wigan Athletic is the interchange of the wings with Victor Moses during the game itself.

He's a much talented natural left-footed winger who could play at both the wings and is a cheaper option to Ashley Young and Eden Hazard. A £10 million fee should be enough to bring him to Anfield.

Pace, power, strength and stamina could sum up Charles N'Zogbia.

3. Milan " The Never Appearing" Jovanovic

?

Jova: LOL'ing on Liverpool every week upon receiving 60,000 quid for nothing
Clint Hughes/Getty Images

Is there any reason why the "mighty" Serbian is at Liverpool in the first place?

The recent reports suggest that Wolfsburg made a £6 million bid for Milan Jovanovic in the January transfer window, only to be rejected by the Reds. But, interestingly enough, the fact of the matter, according to inside reports, was that the player himself rejected the move!!!

Now, how many of Liverpool's fans wished the deal would've gone through? At least I was one of those.

A £6 million fee for the Jova would be a dream come true.

The player must simply be laughing every week when he receives a FAT £60,000 paycheck for not playing forthe club.

The 30-year-old scored an ever importantgoal for Serbia in FIFA World Cup 2010 and that gave everyone a glimpse of why Rafa Benitez made no secrets of bringing the player to Anfield in last summer.

He was given a good run in Europa League by Roy Hodgson. But like the Englishman, King Kenny Dalglish seems to be not interested in playing him in the league as well.

The 2010 Bosman transfer is not a bad player, it's just he is surplus at Liverpool.

The most impressive of his career spell was between 2006-10 at Standard Leige where he scored 69 goals in over 140 appearances which made him a bright late 20s or early 30s prospect.

Rafa's only reason for signing the30-year-old Serbian international would be money constraints at Liverpoolpre-FSG era.

Now that the money is not a problem but the age is, Liverpool should part with the player if Wolfsburg come knocking on the door again in summer.

Possible Replacements:

Not needed.

4. Paul " Roy's Pet" Konchesky

?

Konchesky: A bad scouse dream?
Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images

Arguably one of the worst signings of Roy Hodgson- the former Liverpool Manager.

It is very well known that football managers tend to bring a player or two with themwhen theyleave one club for another. For this matter, Liverpool fans would have forgiven Roy Hodgson if hehad brought anyone but Koncheskyin last summer.

Paul Konchesky is one of the most experienced left backs in Premier League but he, like Roy Hodgson, was at a wrong club.

The hoof-ball mastermind knows everything Roy Hodgson taught him during his Fulham years and found himself out of favour when King Kenny was established as Liverpool manager in January.

He was accused of being too mediocre and his performances didn't help rectify his cause either.

The worse part of the whole failure was that he was brought in to fulfill the mostdreadful of positions in Liverpool team. The left backposition.

Many people would havereceived a "Doctorate" degree by submitting their thesison " Liverpool must strengthen Left back (and Left midfield) ASAP with QUALITY player."

If that was not enough, the Englishman's mother made sure her son would receive enough wrath from Liverpool fans by suggesting Liverpool fans are "Scouse Scum" after their defeat at Stoke City.

Kenny Dalglish clearly knew the ex-Fulham left back was not up to the task and sent him on loan to Nottingham Forest during the January transfer window and appointed Glen Johnson on the role.

Out of everyone's surprise, Johnson has been giving his best performances on the totally opposite side of his normal playing position.

The 29-year-old Konchesky will definitely be out of Anfield in summer. One of the possible destinations is back at Craven Cottage where Mark Hughes seems to be interested in the left back.

Possible Replacement:

1. Taye Taiwo:

The 25-year-old Nigerian football player currently plays at Olympique de Marseille at left back position.

This month, Taiwo clearly made his intentions to move away from OM club clear when he said he will not be signing the contract extension next season.

World football seems to be devoid of enough quality left backs these days. Taiwo's physical presence makes him a distinguish left back.

Pace, power and high crossing ability come with Taiwo, whose contract expires at the end of the season making him free agent.

It seems like the Nigerian has already picked his club for his free transfer in summer. He was quoted saying his agent alongside him are in advanced talks with a club in one of the top three leagues in the world.

Could this club be Liverpool? Only time will tell.

2. Fabio Coentrao:

Perhaps the best, or one of the best, left backs in world football. The Benfica left wing back is considered as one of the highest priced left back and has been linked with Man Utd and Real Madrid.

The 22-year-old Portuguese can also play as a left winger but primarily he is employed at left back position.

Rumours were suggesting he reportedly said "I love Liverpool" which might suggest his interest in the Anfield club.

Coentrao also said that he would be interested in being coached by the special one, Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid.

Since Patrice Evra signed a new four-year deal, Man Utd most likely will not be chasing the Portuguese. That leaves Real Madrid as the major threat to Liverpool for Coentrao's signature.

Coentrao will cost about £25 million should FSG, along with Damien Comolli, decide to finally put an end to the troublesome left back headache at the club.

Conclusion

?

Andy Carrol, Kenny Dalglish and Luis Suarez: All Liverpool need is a few more of these quality
Alex Livesey/Getty Images

Kenny Dalglish's Anfield revolution will not be completed unless the club removes these dead woods and replace them with some quality players just how they did in January.

A final team should look more threatening on every aspect of the pitch.

GK: Pepe Reina, Brad Jones

Full Backs: Glen Johnson, Martin Kelly, Fabio Coentrao/ Taye Taiwo, Fabio Aurelio.

Centre Backs: Jamie Carragher, Daniel Agger, Martin Skrtel, Soto, Wilson

Defensive Midfielders: Lucas Leiva, Christian Poulsen

Attacking Midfielders: Steven Gerrard, Raul Meireles, Keisuke Honda, Jonjo Shelvey, Alberto Aquilani

Wingers: Eden Hazard, Ashley Young/ Charles N'Zogbia, Dirk Kuyt

Strikers: Andy Carroll, Luis Suarez, David N'gog

Conclusion:

At the end of the day, Liverpool will need to spend about the same money they spent during January transfer window to make sure they are finally ready for a revolution next season.

Of course these are the possibilities without taking into consideration of two major futuristic activities.

1. The possibility of other then the listed players wanting to leave the club in summer

2. Kenny Dalglish's interest in youth development may restrict the in-flux of new players.
 
Well thought out mate. Considering we didn't spend anything in the January window, we should be able to invest some decent cash in the summer. Young and great workrate are 2 great attributes to focus on. It isn't good enough to be good anymore...just look at Balotelli and other City players.
 
" May actually have spent the whole game hiding in an underground burrow with some rabbits."

HAHAHAHAHAAA !!!
 
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288334#msg1288334 date=1298216095]

Defensive Midfielders: Lucas Leiva, Christian Poulsen

[/quote]

Not impressed.

I'm looking forward to a mass exodus this summer:

Milan Jovanovi? not good enough
Jay Spearing not good enough
Christian Poulsen not good enough
Maxi Rodríguez not good enough
Joe Cole not good enough
Paul Konchesky not good enough
Stephen Darby not good enough
Daniel Ayala promising but we have better
Nabil El Zhar not good enough
Alberto Aquilani would love it if he came back but doesn't look likely
Philipp Degen not good enough
Emiliano Insúa not good enough

Sum total:
£ 30 - 40 Million?

We could afford to let Soto go and promote Wilson.
We could sell Skrtel and replace him with a top defender. Cahill vs Carra or Agger?

It'll be an interesting summer hopefully.
 
Honda and taiwo for me. strong and clever without the hype the others listed have. Young goes missing as much as riera did, coentrao (or whatever) could be excellent but he's very attack mided, leaving us with 2 ful backs who are so so at defending. I would love hazard though, but I don't think he'd come to us.
 
[quote author=iseered link=topic=44291.msg1288367#msg1288367 date=1298222009]
Wait a minute, we still own Degen, Insua and El Zhar?
[/quote]

You forgot...ahh ignorence is bliss as they say.

They are all out on loan.
 
[quote author=Broseidon link=topic=44291.msg1288374#msg1288374 date=1298223191]
I saw the same exact article on bleacher report
[/quote]
He hasn't taken any credit for writing it. It's kinda obvious that it's a copy/paste.
 
It is the same report if you see the writers credits start off the article. It is well thought out without the stats overload that Tompkins sometimes blast us with.

I pretty sure that there'll be a mass summer exodus to drive down the wage bill but only 3-4 first teamers at the most. Jova, Poulsen, Maxi, Cole, Kyrgiakos/Skrtel and Konchesky at the very least.

Identify and negotiate with our summer targets early to prevent price wars.

Kenny will look to a smaller squad with greater quality backed up by youth. That is a workable solution.

Coentrao is an exciting player but £25M is inflated and we do have super young talent that will graduate in that position over the next few years. Taiwo on a free makes sense leaving a larger pool of transfer funds for attacking talent like Hazard, Young, Turan, Marin, N'zogbia etc. Get in early for Hazard at Lille because the quoted £21M is worth it.

A sign of progress is when Lucas and Kuyt are squad players. Experience on the bench makes all the difference.
 
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288384#msg1288384 date=1298225726]
It is the same report if you see the [glow=red,2,300]writers credits start off the article[/glow]. It is well thought out without the stats overload that Tompkins sometimes blast us with.

[glow=red,2,300]I pretty [/glow]sure that there'll be a mass summer exodus to drive down the wage bill but only 3-4 first teamers at the most. Jova, Poulsen, Maxi, Cole, Kyrgiakos/Skrtel and Konchesky at the very least.

Identify and negotiate with our summer targets early to prevent price wars.

Kenny will look to a smaller squad with greater quality backed up by youth. That is a workable solution.

Coentrao is an exciting player but £25M is inflated and we do have super young talent that will graduate in that position over the next few years. Taiwo on a free makes sense leaving a larger pool of transfer funds for attacking talent like Hazard, Young, Turan, Marin, N'zogbia etc. Get in early for Hazard at Lille because the quoted £21M is worth it.

A sign of progress is when Lucas and Kuyt are squad players. Experience on the bench makes all the difference.


[/quote]


[quote author=My_Blood_Bleeds_Red link=topic=44291.msg1288431#msg1288431 date=1298233495]
you typed *all* that on your mobile device ???
[/quote]

Impressive. I'm useless even with a spell checker.
 
Excellent post and I agree with all of of it. If the 4 mentioned were replaced with the targets mooted we'd be laughing up the table..
 
Get Themn in here, he could do with a lesson in how to post from a Blackberry.
 
[quote author=Modo link=topic=44291.msg1288433#msg1288433 date=1298233914]
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288384#msg1288384 date=1298225726]
It is the same report if you see the [glow=red,2,300]writers credits start off the article[/glow]. It is well thought out without the stats overload that Tompkins sometimes blast us with.

[glow=red,2,300]I pretty [/glow]sure that there'll be a mass summer exodus to drive down the wage bill but only 3-4 first teamers at the most. Jova, Poulsen, Maxi, Cole, Kyrgiakos/Skrtel and Konchesky at the very least.

Identify and negotiate with our summer targets early to prevent price wars.

Kenny will look to a smaller squad with greater quality backed up by youth. That is a workable solution.

Coentrao is an exciting player but £25M is inflated and we do have super young talent that will graduate in that position over the next few years. Taiwo on a free makes sense leaving a larger pool of transfer funds for attacking talent like Hazard, Young, Turan, Marin, N'zogbia etc. Get in early for Hazard at Lille because the quoted £21M is worth it.

A sign of progress is when Lucas and Kuyt are squad players. Experience on the bench makes all the difference.


[/quote]


[quote author=My_Blood_Bleeds_Red link=topic=44291.msg1288431#msg1288431 date=1298233495]
you typed *all* that on your mobile device ???
[/quote]

Impressive. I'm useless even with a spell checker.

[/quote]

I copied the article and pasted it but yeah, I'm pretty handy with a cell phone. I had the time. No Liverpool games this weekend which was pretty crappy.

Spell checker? No time to use it and I figure that the lads will forgive me for the odd mistake if its worth reading.
 
[quote author=Modo link=topic=44291.msg1288365#msg1288365 date=1298221724]
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288334#msg1288334 date=1298216095]

Defensive Midfielders: Lucas Leiva, Christian Poulsen

[/quote]

I'm looking forward to a mass exodus this summer:

Milan Jovanovi? not good enough
Jay Spearing not good enough
Christian Poulsen not good enough
Maxi Rodríguez not good enough
Joe Cole not good enough
Paul Konchesky not good enough
Stephen Darby not good enough
Daniel Ayala promising but we have better
Nabil El Zhar not good enough
Alberto Aquilani would love it if he came back but doesn't look likely
Philipp Degen not good enough
Emiliano Insúa not good enough

Sum total:
£ 30 - 40 Million?
[/quote]

£30-£40 Million for that steaming pile of turd? We'd do well.
 
[quote author=Modo link=topic=44291.msg1288365#msg1288365 date=1298221724]
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288334#msg1288334 date=1298216095]

Defensive Midfielders: Lucas Leiva, Christian Poulsen

[/quote]

Not impressed.

I'm looking forward to a mass exodus this summer:

Milan Jovanovi? not good enough
Jay Spearing not good enough
Christian Poulsen not good enough
Maxi Rodríguez not good enough
Joe Cole not good enough
Paul Konchesky not good enough
Stephen Darby not good enough
Daniel Ayala promising but we have better
Nabil El Zhar not good enough
Alberto Aquilani would love it if he came back but doesn't look likely
Philipp Degen not good enough
Emiliano Insúa not good enough

Sum total:
£ 30 - 40 Million?

We could afford to let Soto go and promote Wilson.
We could sell Skrtel and replace him with a top defender. Cahill vs Carra or Agger?

It'll be an interesting summer hopefully.
[/quote]

What are you on?
s
£30-40 for that lot, as if!

Aqua £10-15m.
Joe cole £4m
the rest, frikking peanuts.

we'll be looking at a shade over £25 if all those go probably.

Even then, thats like what, 12 players going out? Our squad is a joke so obviously the majority of those outgoings will need a replacement. Say 3 younglings get promoted to fill some of the voids, say we need 7 players.

That's an expensive summer, either that or we go bargain bin shopping again and find ourselves in the same situation in 12 months time..
 
[quote author=Halmeister link=topic=44291.msg1288661#msg1288661 date=1298284333]

£30-£40 Million for that steaming pile of turd? We'd do well.
[/quote]

Yep, I feel these sell lists are almost always pure fantasy. Because of their high wages getting any kind of fees for the likes of Konchesky, Degen etc. will be very difficult. With us having to pay part of their wages for anyone to take them we'll probably end up losing money when they are shipped away.
 
a lot of the players listed (on the out list) are on huge wages and are 30 or nearing 30. we'll be hard pressed to shift that lot. hopefully the 'ins' wont be dependent on the 'outs'. if nesv's main concern is the wage bill then they may have to sell them at a huge loss just to get them off the books.
 
[quote author=Hardcastle link=topic=44291.msg1288664#msg1288664 date=1298284595]
Our squad is a joke so obviously the majority of those outgoings will need a replacement. [/quote]

the biggest joke about the squad is the number of players on massive wages who contribute (play) once in a blue moon.
you say these players need 'replacing' but does a player like jova (for example) need 'replacing' he never plays. the likes of lucas needs 'replacing' jova, el zar, etc just need fucking off, there is no slack to pick up as these players hardly ever play.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=44291.msg1288675#msg1288675 date=1298285646]
[quote author=Hardcastle link=topic=44291.msg1288664#msg1288664 date=1298284595]
Our squad is a joke so obviously the majority of those outgoings will need a replacement. [/quote]

the biggest joke about the squad is the number of players on massive wages who contribute (play) once in a blue moon.
you say these players need 'replacing' but does a player like jova (for example) need 'replacing' he never plays. the likes of lucas needs 'replacing' jova, el zar, etc just need fucking off, there is no slack to pick up as these players hardly ever play.
[/quote]I think i know why El Zhar hardly ever plays.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=44291.msg1288675#msg1288675 date=1298285646]
[quote author=Hardcastle link=topic=44291.msg1288664#msg1288664 date=1298284595]
Our squad is a joke so obviously the majority of those outgoings will need a replacement. [/quote]

the biggest joke about the squad is the number of players on massive wages who contribute (play) once in a blue moon.
you say these players need 'replacing' but does a player like jova (for example) need 'replacing' he never plays. the likes of lucas needs 'replacing' jova, el zar, etc just need fucking off, there is no slack to pick up as these players hardly ever play.
[/quote]

I'm not against promoting some of the youth players.
 
If you take the whole squad in its entirety, there are way too many average players who don't contribute that must be moved on. I can't wait for the summer. One of the problems we have though is the amount of high earners. Sell for fees and use the fees to pay up their contracts if we must. Short-term pain for long-term gain.

That leaves us with plenty of space for the youth stars that Kenny has earmarked as the future of the club.
 
[quote author=Modo link=topic=44291.msg1288681#msg1288681 date=1298285908]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=44291.msg1288675#msg1288675 date=1298285646]
[quote author=Hardcastle link=topic=44291.msg1288664#msg1288664 date=1298284595]
Our squad is a joke so obviously the majority of those outgoings will need a replacement. [/quote]

the biggest joke about the squad is the number of players on massive wages who contribute (play) once in a blue moon.
you say these players need 'replacing' but does a player like jova (for example) need 'replacing' he never plays. the likes of lucas needs 'replacing' jova, el zar, etc just need fucking off, there is no slack to pick up as these players hardly ever play.
[/quote]

I'm not against promoting some of the youth players.
[/quote]

I think that is the way forwards. if you have a core group of 16 players that contribute week in week out then they should be back up by youth players this way their wages are small and when they hardly play it's not a big deal because they are getting getting in the reserves. you can then take the money you would have spent on 'experience' that pad out the sqaud and hardly contribute on make the 'core 16' better.
it would be worth taking a hit on transfer fees on the likes of joe cole and jova to make that happen but what you lose on the transfer fee you make back in saved wages over the term of their contract.
 
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288689#msg1288689 date=1298286514]
If you take the whole squad in its entirety, there are way too many average players who don't contribute that must be moved on. [/quote]

to my mind it's doesn't matter if they are average or talented, if they aren't playing they aren't contributing so there is no point them being here. I actually think aqualini is a very talented football but he doesn't suit any system we play so there is zero point him being here. same with joe cole, talented player but where does he fit? I thought the exact same thing with keane, half that money (let alone all 20m) could have been spent on a 'competent' wide player player and we would have had more value for money with a player who would have played more often than not.

our transfer policy seemed to have been picking up talented players for the sack of being talented players without having a set position for them in the team.

we would be so much better served if our transfer policy was;

a) get someone clearly in the position better than the current player we have.
is poulsen 'clearly' better than lucas?

b) get someone 'competent' in a position we essentially have no one.
why buy keane when we clearly needed a wide player.

we'll have to see if we've learnt from our mistakes.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=44291.msg1288693#msg1288693 date=1298287164]
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288689#msg1288689 date=1298286514]
If you take the whole squad in its entirety, there are way too many average players who don't contribute that must be moved on. [/quote]

to my mind it's doesn't matter if they are average or talented, if they aren't playing they aren't contributing so there is no point them being here. I actually think aqualini is a very talented football but he doesn't suit any system we play so there is zero point him being here. same with joe cole, talented player but where does he fit? I thought the exact same thing with keane, half that money (let alone all 20m) could have been spent on a 'competent' wide player player and we would have had more value for money with a player who would have played more often than not.

our transfer policy seemed to have been picking up talented players for the sack of being talented players without having a set position for them in the team.

we would be so much better served if our transfer policy was;

a) get someone clearly in the position better than the current player we have.
is poulsen 'clearly' better than lucas?

b) get someone 'competent' in a position we essentially have no one.
why buy keane when we clearly needed a wide player.

we'll have to see if we've learnt from our mistakes.
[/quote]

Spidey: with reference to what you just said, is it not shocking that this would be a logical and common sense approach to transfers at any club and still we missed the boat. When we did get the boat, we ended up the creek with one paddle!
 
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288706#msg1288706 date=1298288317]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=44291.msg1288693#msg1288693 date=1298287164]
[quote author=RolandG link=topic=44291.msg1288689#msg1288689 date=1298286514]
If you take the whole squad in its entirety, there are way too many average players who don't contribute that must be moved on. [/quote]

to my mind it's doesn't matter if they are average or talented, if they aren't playing they aren't contributing so there is no point them being here. I actually think aqualini is a very talented football but he doesn't suit any system we play so there is zero point him being here. same with joe cole, talented player but where does he fit? I thought the exact same thing with keane, half that money (let alone all 20m) could have been spent on a 'competent' wide player player and we would have had more value for money with a player who would have played more often than not.

our transfer policy seemed to have been picking up talented players for the sack of being talented players without having a set position for them in the team.

we would be so much better served if our transfer policy was;

a) get someone clearly in the position better than the current player we have.
is poulsen 'clearly' better than lucas?

b) get someone 'competent' in a position we essentially have no one.
why buy keane when we clearly needed a wide player.

we'll have to see if we've learnt from our mistakes.
[/quote]

Spidey: with reference to what you just said, is it not shocking that this would be a logical and common sense approach to transfers at any club and still we missed the boat. When we did get the boat, we ended up the creek with one paddle!
[/quote]


a) get someone clearly in the position better than the current player we have.
is poulsen 'clearly' better than lucas?

I guess some people would say 'like DUH!' to the above statement but my point is if the player you are purchasing isn't 'clearly' better than the player you have then save your money for someone that is and use a youth player to pick up the slack until that time. hindsight is 20/20 but we could have saved the 5 million from the poulsen deal and used jonjo as back up. as it stands we have to players at the same level (lucas/poulsen) and paid 5m (and big wages) for it.
 
I don't think anyone would say 'DUH' because thats exactly what we should be doing in the first place. Its so glaringly obvious.

More credence was lent to the politics at the club instead of footballing operations and strategy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom