[quote author=Mystic link=topic=48393.msg1470172#msg1470172 date=1327494032]
[quote author=Fabio link=topic=48393.msg1470169#msg1470169 date=1327493739]
[quote author=Mystic link=topic=48393.msg1470138#msg1470138 date=1327488019]
[quote author=Dahuge link=topic=48393.msg1470133#msg1470133 date=1327487780]
Shelvey, Gerrard and Hendo would leave massive holes in the middle of the park. They are all forward thinking midfielders, we would get fucking battered with that 3 in the middle.
[/quote]
Henderson tracks runners, its Gerrard and Adam that don't.
[/quote]
Again, he tracks them, but he doesn't throw in a tackle, thus making the tracking redundant
Shelvey will play where he is told to play and do a good job. He came on as left back at the tail end of last season and gave an accomplished late cameo in that role.
Jonjo could play the DM role better than anyone else while we're struggling there
[/quote]
It isn't irrelevant, tracking them puts pressure on them and stop them waltzing through like they did on Saturday. And he does put in a tackle, just not as often as he might.
[/quote]
Of course its irrelevant. What pressue does it put them under when he stand 6 yards off them? He tracks the run and when they slow down he casually jogs 8 yards before.
He's not defensive minded. At all. Shelvey has at least shown some defensive ability and, most importantly, balls in a challenge.