• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Player of the Season 2017/8

Forums Unread posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Morse

Morse

Very Active
Honorary Member
Hello everyone.

Most will know me. I am a visitor to quite a few LFC sites and have been the custodian of the Player of the Season game for over 13 years now. The game has spanned many different sites in its time; currently the voters come from YNWA, Est1892, 6CM, Scouser Tommy, TLW, and IrishKop. I am hoping that adding voters from other sites will give a more accurate picture of our feelings as Liverpool supporters.

I hope that you will all play a part in this 14th year to enable us to get a picture of our players' performances and to crown a worthy winner come May 2018.

Previous winners:

2005 Jamie Carragher
2006 Steven Gerrard
2007 Dirk Kuyt
2008 Javier Mascherano
2009 Xabi Alonso
2010 Javier Mascherano
2011 Steven Gerrard
2012 Luis Suarez
2013 Luis Suarez
2014 Luis Suarez
2015 Philippe Coutinho
2016 Lucas Leiva
2017 Philippe Coutinho

This season, the format will be as follows:
Instead of voting for a single player as your Man of the match, you vote for your top 3. This enables a "steady Eddie" like Clyne or Hendo to get his mentions and gain some points. Points are the same as last year; the top player gets 5 points, the second player gets 3 and the third player gets a single point.

This year though, with the help of Dan Smyth, we have got a survey site to keep the tally easier for me.

I will award a bonus half point if our Goalkeeper keeps a clean sheet.

All competitive games are counted, CC, FA, Europa/Champions League and, of course, Premier League matches.

I shall post current league tables so that we can follow the players' performances throughout the season.

If a moderator could ensure a "sticky" when I post a Man of the Match thread, I would be grateful; also it would be nice if I could have a sticky league table thread for the game throughout the season.

Thanks for your support in this.

Getting 6 or more different Liverpool sites to vote throughout a whole season gives a good indication of the fans' feelings on players.
I look forward to collecting and calculating the results throughout the season.

YNWA.

Stu.
 
Result: Game 1 - Watford - Away - PL.
.
1. Mane..................115 votes................5 points
2. Salah..................109 votes................3 points
3. Firmino.................60 votes.................1 point.
No clean sheet bonus.
.
Good start for the new boy!.
Typical LFC last minute giveaway.
.
1st table.
.
Sadio Mane................................................1MOM.................................................................................5 points
Mohamed Salah..................................................................12nd...........................................................3 points
Roberto Firmino.......................................................................................13rd.......................................1 point.
.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).
.
Thanks for voting.
.
YNWA JFT96.
 
Result: Game 2 - Hoffenheim - Away - CLQ
.
1. Mane..............................175 votes.........................5 points
2. Arnold.............................148 votes.........................3 points
3. Mignolet............................89 votes.........................1 point.
No clean sheet bonus.
.
Trent doing an amazing job.
Halfway there...
.
Current table.
.
Sadio Mane................................................2MOM.................................................................................10 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.......................................................12nd...........................................................3 points
Mohamed Salah..................................................................12nd...........................................................3 points
Simon Mignolet.........................................................................................13rd.......................................1 point
Roberto Firmino.......................................................................................13rd.......................................1 point.

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.

.

YNWA JFT96.
 
Result: Game 3 - Crystal Palace - Home - PL
.
1. Andrew Robertson.............................152 votes..............................5 points
2. Sadio Mane........................................118 votes..............................3 points
3. Joel Matip.............................................95 votes...............................1 point
.
New boy gets it!
.
Current table.

.

Sadio Mane.............................................. .2MOM................12nd..................... ....................................13 points
Andrew Robertson......................................1MOM...................................................................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................ ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Mohamed Salah............................................. .....................12nd......................... ..................................3 points
Simon Mignolet.......................................... ..............................................13rd...............1CSB...............1.5 points
Joel Matip..................................................................................................13rd........................................1 point
Roberto Firmino........................................... ............................................13rd.. .....................................1 point.

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.

.

YNWA JFT96.
 
Result: Game 4 - Hoffenheim - Home - CLQ
.
1. Roberto Firmino.....................122 votes..................5 points
2. Sadio Mane.............................89 votes...................3 points
3. Emre Can................................64 votes....................1 point.
No CSB.
.
Job done!
.
Current table.

.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..................... ....................................16 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM.....................................13rd.. .....................................6 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM................................................. ..................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Mohamed Salah...........................................................12nd......................... ..................................3 points
Simon Mignolet.................................................................................13rd ...............1CSB...............1.5 points
Emre Can.........................................................................................13rd.........................................1 point
Joel Matip..................................................................................... ...13rd.........................................1 point


.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.

.

YNWA JFT96.
 
Result: Game 5 - Arsenal - Home - PL

.

1. Emre Can........................98 votes......................5 points

2. Mo Salah.........................75 votes......................3 points

3. Sadio Mane.....................41 votes......................1 point.

CSB.....................................Loris Karius................0.5 point.

.



Sublime.

.

Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............13rd......................................17 points
Mohamed Salah............................................. ..............22nd......................... ..................................6 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... ...............................13rd.. .....................................6 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM.....................................................................................5 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM........ ......................................... ..................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Simon Mignolet.......................................... .......................................13rd ...............1CSB...............1.5 points
Emre Can............................................... ..........................................13rd.... .....................................1 point
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius.............................................................................................................1CSB...............0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 6 - Man City - Away - PL

.

1. Simon Mignolet..............................51 votes.......................5 points

2. Mo Salah.......................................31 votes.......................3 points

3. Sadio Mane...................................16 votes.......................1 point.

No clean sheet bonus.

.

Goalkeeper is MOM after losing 5-0???

Fuck.

.

Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............23rd......................................18 points
Mohamed Salah............................................. ..............32nd......................... ..................................9 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM....................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... ...............................13rd.. .....................................6 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM.....................................................................................5 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM........ ......................................... ..................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Emre Can............................................... ..........................................13rd.... .....................................1 point
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius.............................................................................................................1CSB...............0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 7 - Sevilla - Home - CL.

.

1. Mohamed Salah...........................62 votes..........................5 points

2. Roberto Firmino...........................23 votes..........................3 points

3. Sadio Mane..................................21 votes..........................1 point.

.

Wasteful.

.

Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd......................................19 points
Mohamed Salah.................................1MOM................32nd......................... .................................14 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .....................................9 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM....................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM.....................................................................................5 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM........ ......................................... ..................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Emre Can............................................... ..........................................13rd.... .....................................1 point
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius.............................................................................................................1CSB...............0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ...............................19 points
Mohamed Salah.................................1MOM........ ........32nd......................... .................................14 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .....................................9 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ...................................13rd........................................6 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM........ ......................................... ..................................5 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 9 - Burnley - Home - PL
.
1. Salah..........................42 votes......................5 points
2. Robertson...................15 votes......................3 points
3. Matip.............................6 votes......................1 point.
.
No-one voted other than Mo for MOM.
Him and Phil now joint top.
.
Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ...............................19 points
Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM........ ........32nd......................... .................................19 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .....................................9 points
Andrew Robertson.............................1MOM........ .......12nd.............................................................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ...................................13rd........... .............................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd.............................................................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...23rd.........................................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 9 - Leicester City - Away - LC
.
1. Robertson---------------------15 votes-------------------5 points
2. Coutinho-----------------------12 votes-------------------3 points
3. Solanke--------------------------4 votes-------------------1 point.
.
Disappointing, but good first half performance.
Phil's first points this season.
Low voting turnout.
I didn't add Ward to the choice list, apologies. He will get 0.5 point to put this right.
.
Current table.
.

Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ...............................19 points
Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM........ ........32nd......................... .................................19 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd.............................................................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .....................................9 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ...................................13rd........... .............................6 points
Philippe Coutinho.........................................................12nd.............................................................3 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd.............................................................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ...23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke...............................................................................13rd..........................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point
Danny Ward........................................................................................................Forgotten Man.......0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 10 - Leicester City - Away - PL
.
1. Coutinho----------------------57 votes-------------------5 points
2. Henderson--------------------33 votes-------------------3 points
3. Salah---------------------------24 votes-------------------1 point.
No clean sheet bonus.
.
We got them back.
First MOM for Phil.
Mo goes top!!
Amazing that AR is 3rd ...but he is MOM whenever he plays!
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM................32nd.............13rd........................................20 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ...............................19 points

Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... ....................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. ......................................9 points
Philippe Coutinho................................1MOM...............12nd............................... ..............................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd........... .............................6 points

Jordan Henderson........................................................12nd.............................................................3 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ....23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke...............................................................................13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man.......0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 11 - Spartak Moscow - Away - CL
.
1. Henderson----------------------35 votes-----------------5 points
2. Coutinho-------------------------30 votes-----------------3 points
3. Moreno---------------------------12 votes-----------------1 point.
.
I thought Alberto was good tonight.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM................32nd.............13rd........................................20 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ...............................19 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... ....................13 points
Philippe Coutinho................................1MOM...............22nd............................... .............................11 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. ......................................9 points
Jordan Henderson..............................1MOM...............12nd..............................................................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd........... .............................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold.................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................ ....23rd.........................................2 points
Alberto Moreno...................................................................................13rd.........................................1 point
Dominic Solanke................................................................................13rd.........................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man.......0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 12 - Newcastle United - Away - PL
.
1. Coutinho---------------------36 votes------------------5 points
2. Moreno-----------------------12 votes------------------3 points
3. Salah--------------------------10 votes------------------1 point.
No clean sheet bonus once again...grrr.
.
Another good game for Bert.
.
Mo and Phil battling for the top.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM................32nd.............23rd..................... ...................21 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd............................... .............................16 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points

Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .......................................9 points
Jordan Henderson..............................1MOM....... ........12nd..............................................................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............1CSB...............6.5 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . .............................6 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................12nd...............13rd....... .................................4 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd.........................................2 points

Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... ................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man.......0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 13 - Manchester United - Home - PL
.
1. Gomez---------------------40 votes------------------5 points
2. Salah------------------------33 votes-----------------3 points
3. Coutinho--------------------14 votes-----------------1 point.
Clean sheet bonus----------Mignolet-----------------0.5 point.
.
Well blow me...a clean sheet!
Good game from Joe.
.
Only one team wanted to win this.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................2MOM................42nd.............23rd..................... ...................24 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd.............13rd.........................................17 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............13rd.. .......................................9 points
Jordan Henderson..............................1MOM....... ........12nd..............................................................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............2CSB................7 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . .............................6 points
Joe Gomez.........................................1MOM......................................................................................5 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................12nd...............13rd....... .................................4 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points

Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... ................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............1CSB...............0.5 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man.......0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 14 - NK Maribor - Away - CL
.
1. Salah----------------------------56 votes--------------------5 points
2. Milner----------------------------49 votes--------------------3 points
3. Firmino--------------------------28 votes--------------------1 point.
Clean sheet bonus-----------------Karius--------------------0.5 point.
.

Wow.
Looking forward to the home game now.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................3MOM........ ........42nd.............23rd........................................29 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd.............13rd.................... ....................17 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............23rd.. ......................................10 points
Jordan Henderson..............................1MOM....... ........12nd...................................... ........................8 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............2CSB................7 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . .............................6 points
Joe Gomez.........................................1MOM .................................................. ..................................5 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................12nd...............13rd....... .................................4 points
James Milner................................................................12nd...............................................................3 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... ................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............2CSB.................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man........0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 15 - Tottenham Hotspur - Away - PL
.
1. Salah---------------------------33 votes-------------------5 points
2. Moreno-------------------------10 votes-------------------3 points
3. Gomez---------------------------7 votes-------------------1 point.
.
Shit.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................4MOM........ ........42nd.............23rd........................................34 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd.............13rd.................... ....................17 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............23rd.. ......................................10 points
Jordan Henderson..............................1MOM....... ........12nd..................................... ........................8 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................22nd...............13rd....... .................................7 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............2CSB................7 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . .............................6 points
Joe Gomez.........................................1MOM ....................................13rd..........................................6 points

James Milner............................................ ....................12nd.......................... ...................................3 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... ................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............2CSB.................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man........0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
@Morse, how about giving players a "start bonus" of let's say 0.25 points as to mitigate the situation when a rarely-used player (Robertson this season or Lucas 2 seasons ago) rakes up points in odd appearances ahead of far more important/established players?
 
Result: Game 16 - Huddersfield Town - Home - PL
.
1. Henderson-------------------22 votes----------------5 points
2. Milner--------------------------20 votes----------------3 points
3. Wijnaldum--------------------19 votes----------------1 point.
Clean sheet bonus------------Mignolet----------------0.5 point
.
Good win.
A clean sheet too.
Once again, I have forgotten to include a player in the drop down list. Apologies to A(ox)C.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................4MOM........ ........42nd.............23rd........................................34 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd.............13rd.................... ....................17 points
Jordan Henderson..............................2MOM....... ........12nd.............................................................13 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............23rd.. ......................................10 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............3CSB................7.5 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................22nd...............13rd....... .................................7 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . .............................6 points
Joe Gomez.........................................1MOM ....................................13rd..........................................6 points
James Milner............................................ ....................22nd.......................... ...................................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ..........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd.........................................2 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... ................................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum..........................................................................13rd..........................................1 point
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............2CSB.................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man........0.5 point
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................................................................Forgotten Man........0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 16 - NK Maribor - Home - CL
.
1. Salah-------------------------20 votes--------------------5 points
2. Moreno-----------------------10 votes--------------------3 points
3. Milner--------------------------9 votes---------------------1 point.
Clean sheet bonus-------------Karius---------------------0.5 point.
.
Another clean sheet!
Mo is speeding away with this...but what is happening to Bobby?
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah.................................5MOM................42nd.............23rd..................... ...................39 points
Sadio Mane...................................... .2MOM................22nd..............33rd....... ................................19 points
Philippe Coutinho...............................2MOM...... .........22nd.............13rd.................... ....................17 points
Jordan Henderson..............................2MOM....... ........12nd.............................................................13 points
Andrew Robertson.............................2MOM........ .......12nd....................................... .....................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ ................32nd...............13rd........................................10 points
Roberto Firmino.................................1MOM...... .........12nd.............23rd.. ......................................10 points
Simon Mignolet...................................1MOM... .................................13rd ...............3CSB...............7.5 points

James Milner............................................ ....................22nd.............13rd...........................................7 points
Emre Can...........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... . ..............................6 points
Joe Gomez.........................................1MOM ....................................13rd.......... ................................6 points

Trent Alexander-Arnold..................................... ...........12nd................................... ...........................3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ......................................... ....23rd..........................................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. ...............3CSB...............1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ....................................13rd......... .................................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum..........................................................................13rd............. .............................1 point

Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................. ........Forgotten Man........0.5 point
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................... ............................................Forgotten Man........0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Morse said:
Not sure that would be fair mate.
If Robbo is MOM, why is that less valid?
Click to expand...

Because this way a player who starts a lot of 2nd string matches, cup games etc, and does well in those will accumulate a lot more points than most first-team players the manager relies upon against good opposition. That's how Lucas won his POS awards 2 seasons ago and why Robertson is ahead of Moreno in this season's table even though the reality is Moreno has convincingly won the competition for the LB spot and Robertson cannot get a game.
 
That is one point of view. The other is that AR has played (I think 3 times) and been MOM twice.
 
Result: Game 18 - West Ham - Away - PL
.
1. Salah----------------------------84 votes-------------5 points
2. Firmino--------------------------43 votes-------------3 points
3. Mane-----------------------------29 votes-------------1 point.
No CSB.
.
Boom!
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................6MOM............. ...42nd.............23rd.................................44 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................22nd.............43rd....... .........................20 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................2MOM...... ..........22nd.............13rd.................................17 points
Roberto Firmino............................1MOM...... ..........22nd.............23rd.................................13 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd....................................... ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... .....................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ..............10 points

Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............3CSB.........7.5 points
James Milner.............................................. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd............ .....................6 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM .....................................13rd........... ......................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................12nd................................................ .....3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd........... ......................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................. ................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd.................... .............1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ...............................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.........................................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 19 - Southampton - Home - PL
.
1. Salah, again............................83 votes....................5 points
2. Coutinho.................................23 votes....................3 points
3. Firmino...................................22 votes.....................1 point.
Clean sheet bonus......................Mignolet....................0.5 point.
.
The man seems unstoppable.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................7MOM............. ...42nd.............23rd.................................49 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................22nd.............43rd....... .........................20 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................2MOM...... ..........32nd.............13rd.................................20 points
Roberto Firmino............................1MOM...... ..........22nd.............33rd.................................14 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd....................................... ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... .....................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ..............10 points
Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............4CSB.........8 points
James Milner.............................................. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd............ .....................6 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM .....................................13rd........... ......................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................12nd................................................ .....3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd........... ......................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................. ................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd.................... .............1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ...............................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.........................................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 20 - Sevilla - away - CL
.
1. Firmino---------------------30 votes-----------------5 points
2. Mane------------------------20 votes-----------------3 points
3. Lovren-----------------------7 votes------------------1 point.
No CSB.
.
Feels like a defeat and a 3-0 lead.
First point for Dejan!
.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................7MOM............. ...42nd.............23rd.......................... .......49 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................32nd.............43rd....... ..........................23 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................2MOM...... ..........32nd.............13rd................... ..............20 points
Roberto Firmino............................2MOM...... ..........22nd.............33rd................... ..............19 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd...................................... . ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... ......................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ...............10 points
Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............4CSB..........8 points
James Milner............................................ .. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd......... ... .....................6 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM .....................................13rd......... .. ......................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................ 12nd.............................................. .. .....3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd...... ..... ......................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................ . ................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd...................................1 point
Dejan Lovren................................................................................13rd...................................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................... ..................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 21 - Chelsea - Home - PL
.
1. Salah-----------------------93 votes-------------------5 points
2. Gomez---------------------25 votes-------------------3 points
3. Oxlade Chamberlain----23 votes-------------------1 point.
No CSB.
.
Robbed, we need to convert the "outplaying" games to wins.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................8MOM............. ...42nd.............23rd.......................... .......54 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................32nd.............43rd....... ..........................23 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................2MOM...... ..........32nd.............13rd................... ..............20 points
Roberto Firmino............................2MOM...... ..........22nd.............33rd................... ..............19 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd...................................... . ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... ......................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ...............10 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM ................12nd.............13rd......... .. ......................9 points
Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............4CSB..........8 points
James Milner............................................ .. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd......... ... .....................6 points

Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................ 12nd.............................................. .. .....3 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd...... ..... ......................2 points
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................... .....................13rd......Forgotten Man.....1.5 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB.........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................ . .................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd.................... ...............1 point
Dejan Lovren............................................ ....................................13rd...................................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point


.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 22 - Stoke City - Away - PL
.
1. Salah---------------------42 votes--------------------5 points
2. Mane----------------------34 votes--------------------3 points
3. Oxlade Chamberlain---12 votes--------------------1 point.
Clean sheet bonus--------Mignolet--------------------0.5 point.
.
A clean sheet.
The Ox is picking up points as he improves his fitness.
Mo Salah just keeps amassing his haul of points.
Ladies and Gentlemen, we have a massive star on our hands.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................9MOM............. ...42nd.............23rd.......................... .......59 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................42nd.............43rd....... ..........................26 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................2MOM...... ..........32nd.............13rd................... ..............20 points
Roberto Firmino............................2MOM...... ..........22nd.............33rd................... ..............19 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd...................................... . ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... ......................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ...............10 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM ................12nd.............13rd......... .. ......................9 points
Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............5CSB..........8.5 points
James Milner............................................ .. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd......... ... .....................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................ 12nd.............................................. .. .....3 points
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................... .....................23rd......Forgotten Man.....2.5 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd...... ..... ......................2 points

Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB.........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................ . .................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd.................... ...............1 point
Dejan Lovren............................................ ....................................13rd.......... .........................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Result: Game 23 - Brighton - Away - PL
.
1. Coutinho-------------------------91 votes---------------------5 points
2. Firmino---------------------------74 votes---------------------3 points
3. Salah-----------------------------22 votes----------------------1 point.
No CSB.
.
Phil is back.
.
Current table.
.

Mohamed Salah............................9MOM............. ...42nd.............33rd.......................... .......60 points
Sadio Mane................................. .2MOM.................42nd.............43rd....... ..........................26 points
Philippe Coutinho..........................3MOM...... ..........32nd.............13rd................... ..............25 points
Roberto Firmino............................2MOM...... ..........32nd.............33rd................... ..............22 points
Jordan Henderson.........................2MOM....... ........12nd...................................... . ..............13 points
Andrew Robertson........................2MOM......... .......12nd............................... ......................13 points
Alberto Moreno............................................ .. .........32nd.............13rd.................. ...............10 points
Joe Gomez...................................1MOM ................12nd.............13rd......... .. ......................9 points
Simon Mignolet.............................1MOM... ..................................13rd ..............5CSB..........8.5 points
James Milner............................................ .. .............22nd.............13rd................ .................7 points
Emre Can.....................................1MOM .....................................13rd......... ... .....................6 points
Trent Alexander-Arnold............................................ 12nd.............................................. .. .....3 points
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain....................................... .....................23rd......Forgotten Man.....2.5 points
Joel Matip............................................. ........................................23rd...... ..... ......................2 points
Loris Karius............................................ .................................................. .........3CSB.........1.5 points
Dominic Solanke........................................... ..............................13rd................ . .................1 point
Georginio Wijnaldum......................................... ..........................13rd.................... ...............1 point
Dejan Lovren............................................ ....................................13rd.......... .........................1 point
Danny Ward.............................................. ................................................Forgotten Man.....0.5 point

.

Please use the survey site for your vote as I do not read the individual threads. (Far too busy).

.

Thanks for voting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom