• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The Transfer Window

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fox

Very Active
Member
Surely it makes more sense to have the window closing before the seasons starts.

The next week is going to be carnage, you have players like Dempsey refusing to play maybe in fear of getting injured to ruin his move. You have panic buys from managers after the first two games go wrong.

It's a shit idea and should all be done and dusted before 1st kick off

sort it out FA
 
We were saying this the other day, too much can go wrong during August to influence players decisions.
 
What was the reason for having a transfer window at all? I honestly can't remember, I can't see any advantages to restricting it to certain times of the year.
 
What was the reason for having a transfer window at all? I honestly can't remember, I can't see any advantages to restricting it to certain times of the year.

Course there are when you've got someone like City or Chelsea, neck and neck in a title race and faced with a major injury. There's not much fair play about but at least in that respect it goes some way to addressing it, otherwise they really would be buying the title.
 
Course there are when you've got someone like City or Chelsea, neck and neck in a title race and faced with a major injury. There's not much fair play about but at least in that respect it goes some way to addressing it, otherwise they really would be buying the title.

There are other solutions though. Have a cooling off period where a new signing can't play for the first three games or something, so there aren't rush buys. Or you can only add X number of players to a squad. All the transfer window has led to squads building massive squads with way more players than they need, meaning good players don't even play, and don't have the chance to move, as the clubs keep them as an insurance against an injury.
 
Remember in the good ol' days when we loaned Ronnie Rosenthal for the last 10 games odf the season, and his goals effectively won the league for us - perfect hattrick in his first match away to Charlton (I think).

Then we paid £1M for him to make it permanent & he went to pot
 
I always remember Chelsea being cited as one of the reasons for it, mainly the time they unsettled and eventually signed Parker - scuppering Charltons run at the CL places.

It would be better if it opened in June and closed at the end of Feb.
 
Martin Jol thinks the transfer window should close before the start of the season to stop the kind of "nonsense" he has had to endure over Clint Dempsey's future.

Fulham fined Dempsey after he refused to play for the club in Saturday's game at Norwich, which the Cottagers won 5-0.

The American, who scored 23 goals last season, has his heart set on a move to Liverpool, but the Anfield club have yet to bid for the player despite making an enquiry about him last month.

This summer has seen a number of players in conflict with their clubs over transfers.

Robin van Persie barely played for Arsenal this summer before securing a move to Manchester United while Luka Modric has not played for Tottenham as he has been pining for a transfer to Real Madrid.

This kind of scenario dismays Jol, who believes all clubs should be forced to do their transfer dealings before the start of the season, rather than by the end of August.

"We should stop the window when the first game is played then all this nonsense would stop," the Fulham manager said.

"If you look at the window now with two weeks to go, it's awful because there are a lot of clubs waiting around until they get the money in (from sales) and if they have got the money then they will come in and of course then you have players with clauses as well, so I think we should do something about it.

"It's a bit frustrating. I had the same thing happen to me in Germany (with Hamburg).

"Vincent Kompany left and then (Rafael) van der Vaart left in the same week."
 
Transfer deadline day is one of the most hideous aspects of Sky's ruining of modern football. Fuck the transfer window, it is pointless. It should be fucked off for good.
 
SNA02JIM9---682d_1447234a.jpg
 
Sky is filled with really thoroughly unlikeable people (as you would expect), but there are SOME good things about it.

Well i say some. I mean Millie Clode.
 
Natalie Sawyer is where it's at.

That roll of the tongue over her perfectly formed plump lips is erotically divine and those durrrttttteee eyes *drool*
 
Surely it makes more sense not to have any transfer season per se at all but maybe just not allow major transfers in the last say 3 months of the season (you can work out how to phrase it). Less pressure and I don't doubt lower transfer fees.
 
Yes - along with Jimmy Carter that was one of Dalglish's few poor signings

*retreats to bunker*
Kenny had a very shrewd eye for players back in the 80s. Even Speedie, strange a signing as he seemed, scored against United, and a couple in a win against Everton. Venison was another seemingly strange one, but he fit in well.
Of course then there was the inspired use of the Rushy transfer money on Aldridge, Beardsley and Barnes - and the incredible football that followed.
But there was no excuse for Jimmy Carter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom