[quote author=peekay link=topic=28565.msg720720#msg720720 date=1226463562]
[quote author=Ryan link=topic=28565.msg720716#msg720716 date=1226462198]
[quote author=peekay link=topic=28565.msg720709#msg720709 date=1226460966]
[quote author=Ryan link=topic=28565.msg720654#msg720654 date=1226447083]
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=28565.msg720650#msg720650 date=1226446886]
Hes a terrific batsman tho ay?
[/quote]
Have you seen his recent scores mate? He's in the worst form of his professional life, and he knows it.
Traditionally though, yes he's great. The only constant mainstay in the Australian side is Hussey who's one of, if not the, best batsmen on Earth.
[/quote]
Most indian media are reporting now that a significant majority of OZ media are blaming him for the loss. Is it true ryan?
[/quote]
Very true mate, although I think that's a bit harsh on him. He had a few key players out through injury/suspension/whatever and he came up against a very good Indian side, but he is the captain and he made errors so he's gotta pay the price.
[/quote]
I am surprised at the reaction he is receiving. He has been an exceptional captain. It was always going to be a tough task taking over from Waugh but he has been brilliant.
He did make mistakes but instead of just him I would blame all the senior playes - Lee, Hayden. Whenever Dhoni looked for an inspiration from his players while fielding they delivered. Even part time bowlers delivered crucial wickets. Ponting got nothing from his players. I dont think Waugh would have done any better with this team.
[/quote]
I think the tough task is not taking over from Waugh but leading a once great cricket team through a transitional period were an exceptional bunch of cricketers are at the end of their respective careers.
Any team in the world would be hit by the loss of players of the calibre of Warne, McGrath, Gilchrist, Langer, MacGill and with Hayden surely not far behind. Symmonds is also a loss.
The quality of the younger players, particularly in bowling is just not there in the test team at the moment.