• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Schmack down…

Status
Not open for further replies.

Buddha

Very Well-Known
Member
I’ve not seen this in the other threads (but I’m skim reading so delete if necessary)…and seeing as it’s a day for loss / looking forward - who would you want to replace the legendary Schmadtke?

Schmadtke to step down as Liverpool sporting director next week​

We mentioned him earlier, but Jörg Schmadtke won’t be playing any part in Liverpool’s succession plan. Liverpool have just announced that he will leave the club after the January transfer window.

“We would like to place on record our gratitude to Jörg for the important role he has played since joining Liverpool last summer,” said FSG president Mike Gordon.

“He has made a valuable contribution, both in terms of the support he provided to Jürgen Klopp and the assistance and guidance given to our outstanding football operations department.”
 
There's just no way we are letting all these people go, without some kind of idea about what is coming next. I'm hopeful we have identified our man.
 
There's just no way we are letting all these people go, without some kind of idea about what is coming next. I'm hopeful we have identified our man.
Totally..
It's Xabi and his team.
As for sporting director. You will probably see Edwards back at in an advisory role supporting the new SD in some capacity.
 
There's just no way we are letting all these people go, without some kind of idea about what is coming next. I'm hopeful we have identified our man.
We're bringing back Comolli, Ayre, Rodgers & Pascoe.

Getting the dream team back together again.
 
I do not keep up to date with with sporting directors - it's always hard to judge their impact and who is accountable for what. The club should do what it takes to bring Edwards back into the fold.
 
Liverpool could turn to Bournemouth's Richard Hughes to fill sporting director role after it was revealed Jorg Schmadtke will leave the club

Bournemouth technical director Richard Hughes is emerging as a candidate for the sporting director role at Liverpool in the summer.

The 44-year-old is regarded as someone well equipped to replace Jorg Schmadtke in a new-look structure at Anfield.

Schmadtke is one of a number of faces that are set to leave the Reds, headlined by manager Jurgen Klopp, who announced that he would step down as manager at the end of the season on Friday.

The German joined Liverpool in January 2023 but it was revealed earlier this week that he would be stepping down from his role at the end of the current transfer window.

Hughes, meanwhile, retired from football in 2014 having made over 170 appearances for Bournemouth, also turning out for Grimsby, Portsmouth and the Scotland national team.

The former midfielder joined the Bournemouth technical team under Eddie Howe upon his retirement and was later promoted to technical director.


He has overseen the club's recent success under Andoni IIraola and may be intrigued by the chance to make the step up to Liverpool come the end of the season.



Dated Nov 2023:

 
West Ham chief Tim Steidten is a leading contender to be Liverpool's new director of football. The Reds have begun their search for Jorg Schmadtke's replacement, who is leaving after this month’s window.
 
Graeme Bailey
@GraemeBailey
Liverpool are eyeing up a host of potential replacements for Jorg Schmadtke.Bournemouth's Richard Hughes, Brentford's Lee Dykes and Brighton's Sam Jewell amongst those they have done work on.
 
West Ham chief Tim Steidten is a leading contender to be Liverpool's new director of football. The Reds have begun their search for Jorg Schmadtke's replacement, who is leaving after this month’s window.

WHY THE FK DIDNT WE GO FOR HIM IN THE FIRST PLACE
 
Sam Jewell also sounds like a really interesting candidate. Young but seem to be extremely talented.
 
How do you judge if a DOF is good or not?
Is it signings? If so, what is so impressive with West Ham's and Bournemouth's recent signings?
 
How do you judge if a DOF is good or not?
Is it signings? If so, what is so impressive with West Ham's and Bournemouth's recent signings?

Seems that Steidten was at Leverkusen and Bremen as well before that and was instrumental in signing Frimpong who I guess is a key player for Xabi now.
 
How do you judge if a DOF is good or not?
Is it signings? If so, what is so impressive with West Ham's and Bournemouth's recent signings?

Pretty much, negotiations around signings & how long it takes to conclude.....if you're consistently bringing in #1 targets.......are you paying over the odds every time or are they astute signings, and it works the other way with outgoings.......you see how much acclaim Edwards got for moving on players at the right time.

Then you work on references, how well they communicate between manager and board.....which none of us fans will be privvy to, it's for the club to best decide.
 
How do you judge if a DOF is good or not?
Is it signings? If so, what is so impressive with West Ham's and Bournemouth's recent signings?

Both clubs have been pretty impressive in their team building this season. Kudus to West Ham is probably the stand out signing.
 
Seems that Steidten was at Leverkusen and Bremen as well before that and was instrumental in signing Frimpong who I guess is a key player for Xabi now.
Frimpong was a very good signing
Both clubs have been pretty impressive in their team building this season. Kudus to West Ham is probably the stand out signing.
Kudus turned out to be gem. Can't believe how Man I signed everyone from Ajax except Kudus.

Anyway, seems like a small sample size to judge them on. Going from Leverkusen to West Ham seems more like a lateral move.
I believe it's more like what @binomial said, kinda hard for us fans to judge.
 
Bring in the DoF from BL, he already works with Alonso.... He probably gets a 6 figure salary now, just double or triple it.
Or bring Edwards back
 
Frimpong was a very good signing

Kudus turned out to be gem. Can't believe how Man I signed everyone from Ajax except Kudus.

Anyway, seems like a small sample size to judge them on. Going from Leverkusen to West Ham seems more like a lateral move.
I believe it's more like what @binomial said, kinda hard for us fans to judge.

Not sure about that. From his point of view you are working within a totally different budget in the PL.
He was very impressive at Leverkusen though. I hoped we would go for him when he left Leverkusen.
 
FSG have known since November of the overhaul that was incoming, and have been pursuing a succession plan accordingly. But who is most likely in the frame to replace Schmadtke?

Richard Hughes


Hughes, a former player who once scored a winner in an FA Cup tie against Liverpool for Portsmouth, is highly respected in recruitment circles and has forged his reputation during a lengthy spell at Bournemouth, where he is currently technical director.

He helped bring Nathan Ake, Callum Wilson and Tyrone Mings to the club before they were moved on at a profit, and bought players such as ex-Reds man Dominic Solanke and one-time Liverpool targets Lloyd Kelly and Alex Scott, as well as being influential in Andoni Iraola becoming manager.

Hughes is well known to Liverpool given the dealings between the clubs in recent years, including a loan move for Nat Phillips. Intriguingly, there was speculation in November that Hughes could leave his role at the Cherries at the end of the season.

Tiago Pinto

Pinto is one name who will most definitely be available after it was confirmed earlier this month he will exit his position as Roma general manager at the end of the current transfer window.

The 39-year-old has spent three years at Roma where he worked alongside Jose Mourinho, with the Serie A side winning the Conference League in 2022 and reaching the Europa League final the following year.

He had previously been at Benfica, where he managed the club's multisports division between 2012 and 2017 before becoming director of football in 2017. Pinto, who was last year linked with Tottenham Hotspur, will be in demand with Saudi Pro League side Al-Nassr already reportedly showing an interest.

Tim Steidten

Steidten was only appointed as West Ham United technical director in July but has already impressed with the signing of Mohammed Kudus in particular. There are, though, suggestions he doesn't have a perfect working relationship with Hammers boss David Moyes.

The 44-year-old former player rose through the ranks at Werder Bremen - for whom he signed Serge Gnabry and took Kevin De Bruyne on loan from Chelsea - and became director of football in 2017 before joining Bayer Leverkusen in 2019, where he recruited players such as Moussa Diaby, Jeremie Frimpong and Piero Hincapie.

Among the other signings he helped secure? Xabi Alonso as manager. The Spaniard, of course, is now among the favourites to replace Klopp as Reds boss.

Michael Edwards

Liverpool haven't properly filled the void vacated by Edwards when he departed as sporting director in May 2022. Edwards has subsequently been without a club but has remained working in the game, having formed data consultancy Ludonautics with Liverpool's former director of research Ian Graham. The company is assisting several English clubs at present.

While it would arguably be a no-brainer for Liverpool, Edwards himself has clearly moved on with there being no suggestion he is interested in returning to his old post having served the club with distinction for 11 years.

Paul Mitchell

Mitchell departed his role as Monaco sporting director last summer after three years with the French side. The former player retired aged just 27 in 2009 and has since gained a strong reputation in recruitment, first with MK Dons and then Southampton. He followed then Saints boss Mauricio Pochettino to Tottenham Hotspur in 2014 and later became head of recruitment and development at RB Leipzig.

Working against Mitchell, though, is the fact Liverpool chose not to act on his obvious interest in the sporting director role when it was handed to first Ward and then Schmadtke. He's also strongly fancied to replace Pinto at Roma.

Sven Mislintat

Mislintat was another who was linked with the Liverpool role ultimately filled by Schmadtke last summer. He started as an analyst at Borussia Dortmund before becoming chief scout, signing the likes of Robert Lewandowski, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang, Shinji Kagawa, Ousmane Dembele and Mats Hummels, who were later mostly sold at a huge profit.

However, he did not prove a success as chief scout at Arsenal and then spent three years as sporting director at Stuttgart while a spell at Ajax as director of football lasted just five months before he was sacked last September. A Liverpool move seems highly unlikely.
 
Last edited:
Bayern's Technical Director, Marco Neppe has left the club, with Max Eberl tipped to take over his role.



Dated 2022:
Interview with our Technical Director Marco Neppe: Our squad should have a magnetic effect

FC Bayern had a lot of foresight, for example, in bringing Joshua Kimmich or Alphonso Davies as young hopefuls...

"... and we had conviction! With Serge Gnabry, we also had the issue early on that Franck Ribéry and Arjen Robben were at the tail end of their careers and Serge brought an exciting profile with his individual characteristics. We want the players to know exactly their profile and thus their strengths and weaknesses. Because that is why they are with us. We didn't want to, and couldn't clone, Franck or Arjen, but we expected Serge to be one of the players who could help fill a gap left by the two. This is about one crucial factor: trust. We believe in our players and trust them. Serge has paved his own path with us."

Which transfer is better: a world class superstar who immediately adds shine to the team, or a young talent that develops and hits the ground running

"The best feeling for me is when we have a team that is homogeneous and wins everything. We only achieve that through a special mix. At FC Bayern, the quantity of the squad is special compared to other teams internationally. That's part of our strategy, because we create an environment where the likes of talents like Josip Stanišić, Paul Wanner or Malik Tillman are able to get into the team. Other clubs say they need 25 top international players to achieve their goals. We at FC Bayern are convinced that it can be done differently. One of the things that impresses me about our squad is the willingness of our top players to pass on their experience. The transitions between generations, from Philipp Lahm, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Ribéry and Robben to Manuel Neuer, Thomas Müller, Robert Lewandowski, Kimmich, Leon Goretzka, Alphonso Davies and Jamal Musiala, have been the key to our extraordinary success over the years. Challenging ourselves and encouraging others: That's the FC Bayern spirit. We have to maintain that."
 
Dont let this guy leave...

It was actually Dave Fallows convincing Michael Edwards to change Jurgen Klopp's mind from signing Brandt & instead go for Mohamed Salah per
@Simon_Hughes__
 
Simon Hughes
@Simon_Hughes__

Liverpool will appoint a sporting director before a manager. Examined where that search is at and how FSG got there. Two new names under discussion are Ricky Massara (ex Milan, and available) and Florent Ghisolfi (currently with Nice, a trickier get).
 
Simon Hughes
@Simon_Hughes__

Liverpool will appoint a sporting director before a manager. Examined where that search is at and how FSG got there. Two new names under discussion are Ricky Massara (ex Milan, and available) and Florent Ghisolfi (currently with Nice, a trickier get).

I hear there is a sporting director at Leverkusen who works very well with a certain Spaniard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom