Brad Jones was past his prime.... to put it kindlyWe've probably had a worse keeper than "you know who", but imo not a worse first choice keeper.
He had a prime?Brad Jones was past his prime.... to put it kindly
I'm guessing Arphexad and Carson.I feel like there should be some sort of disqualifier for anybody that didn't actually play more than 20 games. How many would that remove from the above list
Kirkland was semi permanently injured. He wasn't a terrible keeper, just cursed.
Mignolet was... ok, just lacked the personality. Thought he was mismanaged by Rodgers too.
I honestly do not recall seeing Carson or Pegguy play for us, ever.
Brad Jones was actually a lot similar to what Danny Ward was. Capable goalkeepers that made some remarkable saves but ultimately a few errors overshadowed all that and that’s the problem you have being a number 2, you tend to only remember the bad. The same will happen with Kelleher down the line.He had a prime?
Not even the Juve game in 2005?
Westerveld was our steady Eddie keeper. Not terrible, not great, just OK.
I made a list and it just couldn't be two options otherwise there would be no debate. So Carson was thrown in there because he is a Manc now, purely out of bitterness. Kirkland was always injured, huge bugbear of mine. Aphrexed, I just remember him being not the best but can't really remember him playing.
Karius proves it
James nickname was "Calamity James" that's why he made the list! He made quite a few howlers in his time. Was he the worst, by a long way, no! But as i said I had to throw in names. The names you mentioned I couldn't remember ever playing other than Bogdan, but because he was real proper ginger, I felt sorry for him, and couldn't add him to the listWeird though how you've included James in that list who was mostly ok given he's one of the youngest keepers we've ever had.
Where is Doni, Jones, Bogdan, Itandje, Cavalieri.
I know what his nickname was lol but we've stopped giving nicknames out and there's been about 6-7 other keepers that came after him who've all been worst.James nickname was "Calamity James" that's why he made the list! He made quite a few howlers in his time. Was he the worst, by a long way, no! But as i said I had to throw in names. The names you mentioned I couldn't remember ever playing other than Bogdan, but because he was real proper ginger, I felt sorry for him, and couldn't add him to the list
James wasn't terrible, but we had him for too long. It's ridiculous the number of games that he ended up playing for us.
Obviously he was better than all of the long line of crappy back up keepers we had in the following years, and he was better than Karius, Mignolet and Kirkland but he was nowhere near as good as Alisson or Reina and I don't think he was as good as Dudek either. Not much in it between him and Westerveld.
I don't remember Carson. What happened was I accidently pressed "Add another option" , and thought Fuck! What do I do now? Couldn't find the delete button, So I remembered Carson is playing for City, that was reason enough!I know what his nickname was lol but we've stopped giving nicknames out and there's been about 6-7 other keepers that came after him who've all been worst.
How do you remember Carson playing but not Jones or Doni.