I am very open to Xabi starting tomorrow. I do not hold any strong sentimental attachment to him from his playing days. He's a man who will do what's best for Xabi at a time that's right for Xabi, which is fair enough, but there are several reasons why I would make the switch. First, I think he was always the preferred option. Our data people will almost certainly have reams of evidence to back that up. What he achieved at Leipzig should not be overlooked. It was an impressive piece of work, especially given the context and expectations there. Second, we have put a lot of eggs in a Wirtz-shaped basket. He is starting to find his rhythm, but there is arguably no one better placed to maximise his potential and Frimpong’s than Xabi. Third, his education as a player matters. He worked under elite managers throughout his career, and that influence shows. Mourinho once singled him out as the player he coached who was most likely to succeed in management. That is not something to dismiss lightly. Finally, there is the old saying that you are not really a football manager until you have been sacked. He took on what is probably the biggest job in football, too early and under the wrong conditions. That experience will have hurt, but it will also have taught him a huge amount and maybe clipped his wings for the better.
I think the club will hold off making any decision until the summer, though. If relationships improve (if they are strained) and the team click into gear, then who knows. I've seen enough worrisome signs that Slot isn't the one, but now that results have steadied, he's at least earned the right for people to be open-minded. If I had to stake money on it, I'd wager that his stubbornness will be his undoing. It's a trait that's fine when you're winning game after game, but long-term, this model requires some humility and cooperation for it to work; it requires a manager who can blood in youngsters for the squad's benefit, and for generating revenue, it requires a manager whose football can get the crowd on their feet. Unless in dire circumstances, Anfield has been a stadium that mostly responds to what's on the pitch rather than lifting the team during a flat performance, and lastly it requires a manager who can keep morale in the squad up through of combination of personality and giving opportunities. I see them as some core pillars the Liverpool job is assessed against, and unless Slot demonstrates them, it's hard to see how he gets another contract. If results aren't perfect, then there's greater scrutiny on the process and that's why he's firmly under the spotlight.