Isakly what we need (AKA Isak Hunt)
- Thread starter Hansern
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
Lost the will to care.
I’m not against signing Isak, but I wouldn’t be hugely disappointed if we didn’t get him, either. Carragher is right that Ekitike is probably too expensive, and maybe too good, to just be a rotation option. There’s talk of him playing on the left, but I think it could turn into another Gakpo situation. With Riu already there and Wirtz as well, I’m not convinced that was ever the plan. If Ekitike is going to reach Isak’s level, he needs regular games and a settled position. As for Isak, him going on strike doesn't put me off him per se, but it doesn't make me warm to him either, neither to our club if we're orchestrating it.
I’d be happy if the club pivoted, backed their judgement on Ekitike and brought in a versatile forward who can play across the front line. I'm not sure who that is, or whether anyone is good enough and available, beyond maybe Rodrygo, but the principle seems sound to me.
Whatever happens, though, if Isak misses his game against us then that's pretty funny and advantageous, especially given our tough start to the year.
I’d be happy if the club pivoted, backed their judgement on Ekitike and brought in a versatile forward who can play across the front line. I'm not sure who that is, or whether anyone is good enough and available, beyond maybe Rodrygo, but the principle seems sound to me.
Whatever happens, though, if Isak misses his game against us then that's pretty funny and advantageous, especially given our tough start to the year.
Look at our bench tonight and then tell me we don't need him.
Tbf we literally have 3 forwards. Even if Ekitike is nominally 4th choice he'd probably get as many minutes as any of the other 3.
I think it's perfectly clear I never said we don't need quality attackers, and that includes Isak.
I don't agree it's essential we blow £135m on a player who is the exact same profile as we have already spent heavily on. There's always other options, especially for the figures being thrown around.
I don't agree it's essential we blow £135m on a player who is the exact same profile as we have already spent heavily on. There's always other options, especially for the figures being thrown around.
Who do we have in the squad that is the same profile as a 25 year old, proven premier league centre forward goalscorer, who has scored 56 goals in 86 premier league games?
So far, Ekitike looks worth every penny, I wouldn't have said that before signing him.
I get it, but we still need another striker and its pretty late in the window
One way or another we need at least one forward that can cover centre and left.
I’m all for us keeping Cheesie - looks like Slot might actually play him this season - as much as Rio looks amazing, this is his season to be a regular starter in domestic cups and hopefully Dreamies dreams don’t come true and we advance further in those comps with the likes of Rio, Nyoni, Leoni, etc alongside the standard benchwarmers getting minutes.
However, we can’t leave ourselves light up front.
I don’t really see how you couldn’t “want” Isak - he’s the best striker in the world that’s “available”.
I presume the earlier Carragher comments are from Stick to Football where he said Ekitike was too good to not start - which is fair. In that case however, Roy Keane was also right that top class teams need really good competition for places to drive them on.
I could see Isak regularly coming off around that 65th minute substitution with Ekitike getting a good 30 minutes and vice versa in some games keeping them both fresh and sharp for a long season.
Slott also reckons he can play Isak & Ekitike together, which sounds like a good tactical variation (particularly if Mo isn’t available).
Signing Isak improves us.
Personally I’d ignore the fee, because it’s is what it’s going to be, there’s isn’t anyone out there available I see as good enough at half the price.
I’m all for us keeping Cheesie - looks like Slot might actually play him this season - as much as Rio looks amazing, this is his season to be a regular starter in domestic cups and hopefully Dreamies dreams don’t come true and we advance further in those comps with the likes of Rio, Nyoni, Leoni, etc alongside the standard benchwarmers getting minutes.
However, we can’t leave ourselves light up front.
I don’t really see how you couldn’t “want” Isak - he’s the best striker in the world that’s “available”.
I presume the earlier Carragher comments are from Stick to Football where he said Ekitike was too good to not start - which is fair. In that case however, Roy Keane was also right that top class teams need really good competition for places to drive them on.
I could see Isak regularly coming off around that 65th minute substitution with Ekitike getting a good 30 minutes and vice versa in some games keeping them both fresh and sharp for a long season.
Slott also reckons he can play Isak & Ekitike together, which sounds like a good tactical variation (particularly if Mo isn’t available).
Signing Isak improves us.
Personally I’d ignore the fee, because it’s is what it’s going to be, there’s isn’t anyone out there available I see as good enough at half the price.
I honestly think Ekitike would still start on the left anyway.
Yup. Ekitike will be fighting for two positions should Isak arrive. I do wonder what our formation will be like during AFCON. Could we be going for a 4-2-2-2-kind of thing?
Our bench won us the game and we still have Harvey.
soooo if this happens it’s likely to be in the next 10 days. how would newcastle want to time this? obviously they want him out of next mondays game, but would they want a deal agreed before or after?
imo agree a deal on friday, probably too late to play and a furious atmosphere at their place.
imo agree a deal on friday, probably too late to play and a furious atmosphere at their place.
If he’s not had any decent training since May then he wouldn’t start anyway.
An early goal should quiet their traps.
Exactly. We're not going to see him until after the international break.
he’s been playing keepy ups in spain for weeks with his agent though
Silly bugger should have used a ball.
it’s perfect, he’s replacing darwin after all
oh most def.
View: https://x.com/JacobsBen/status/1957444635749466152
This isn't good at all. I really think there's a danger Isak doesn't get done.
I hope the Newcastle fans are laying into Wissa. I won’t be holding my breath.
I saw that moron Shearer on MOTD moaning about how there's a right way to force a move. In support of this he cited Wayne Rooney politely asking for a move to City, which ended with Fergie telling him to get fucked.
If only Isak had thought of that.
Yeah I know, why is Wissa goingbon strike like that !!!
This the same Shearer who blamed the first Brentford goal on Kerkez despite having only been substituted 4 mins prior?
