• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Jost Go

bluebell

Very Well-Known
Member
The season hasn't started and walking sick note has contracted Nabyaitus. Honestly, we need a replacement for him because at this rate he could apply for a Blue Badge. I would love to say sell him, but no one is stupid enough to buy him outside Man U (and they won't due to a unwritten embargo). Eric Garcia of barcelona is the last year of his contract. With Barcelona forced to sell to make room for Rashford could be one solution. He can also play CDM, so selling Endo could fund the transfer

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKhZ8UT_1EY
 
We would need an English player. We’ve got too many foreigners.




Oooo errrrrrrr.
As I said we would have to sell Endo to make it happen. The problem with English players is that they're not cheap. Of the HG options that are likely to be cheap are Adam Webster and John Stones. This is for 4th choice
 
Where would that leave us for DM? Jones and Mac are poor replacements for Gravenberch.
If we are going to Isak and Guehi how do we afford another CB? Jo Go is like an old italian classic lovely to look at, but lucky if it will starts and if it does start it will breakdown within 2 miles of driving. @Frogfish warned me that we need 2 CBs, I thought Jo would survive till Jan, and he is right we need to CBs. Eric Garcia can play CB, RB and CDM. Robbo as 4th choice CB is the wrong choice and Badge is chronically more injury prone than Jo Go
 
We’d still score shit loads without him. Two defenders and a DM better than our wonder ninja seem more important to me.
 
Joego has an injury record that is worse than Keita / Thiago combined. We will probably be getting Guehi in with Joego / Endo as our 4th CB.

Whether we will get someone like Cresswell in depends on Tsimikas. I suspect it won't be easy to shift him so we will probably make do with permacrocked Joego or Endo.
 
We’d still score shit loads without him. Two defenders and a DM better than our wonder ninja seem more important to me.
Depends if there's any defenders worth getting. Guehi, but other than that who's 1) good enough 2) cheap enough to sit on the bench as 4th choice?
 
Had a good season in Klopp's last seeing as he was actually available to cover about at fullback but in the last 4-5 years he's become a bit of a deadweight in the squad and I still wouldn't trust him in a run of games at CB.

Sign a good up and coming u21 player that doesn't need to be registered if we're maxed out on non-HG and go for Guehi in Jan for a cut price.
 
I thought he'd go anyway.
Seriously though, I like him but he can't be relied upon.

What is it with Gomez?
Has he played too much football, considering that he started playing in the Championship at 17.
 
I thought he'd go anyway.
Seriously though, I like him but he can't be relied upon.

What is it with Gomez?
Has he played too much football, considering that he started playing in the Championship at 17.
just another one of those guys who can’t stop getting hurt

…or he’s part of the deal for isak, i doubt they’re that stupid but they’re really struggling to make signings happen
 
We already need 1 CB, selling Gomez means we need 2 and selling Konate means we need 3.

Fine, if we want to do it, but it’s a bit late in the window to pivot to a total defensive rebuild after we’ve seemingly decided it’s the forward line that’s getting revamped.

Just sign Guehi and leave it at that for this summer.
 
We already need 1 CB, selling Gomez means we need 2 and selling Konate means we need 3.

Fine, if we want to do it, but it’s a bit late in the window to pivot to a total defensive rebuild after we’ve seemingly decided it’s the forward line that’s getting revamped.

Just sign Guehi and leave it at that for this summer.
No one's buying Gomez unless they're stupid. Will he be available for games we need him for? There's hope Konate will sign a new contract. Going into the new season with Guehi, Konate and VVD, is that enough knowing Konate can breakdown?
 
We already need 1 CB, selling Gomez means we need 2 and selling Konate means we need 3.

Fine, if we want to do it, but it’s a bit late in the window to pivot to a total defensive rebuild after we’ve seemingly decided it’s the forward line that’s getting revamped.

Just sign Guehi and leave it at that for this summer.

We need 2 inspite of Gomez.

There's over a full calendar month left in the window, more than enough time to find a back up CB option or 2, a Klavan/Coates type will do fine.
 
We need 2 inspite of Gomez.

There's over a full calendar month left in the window, more than enough time to find a back up CB option or 2, a Klavan/Coates type will do fine.

Yeah, ok I take your point but the 4th choice CB isn’t going to play much outside of domestic cups or in case of an injury.

I get that Gomez spends loads of time injured, but that’s also loads of time not complaining about not getting a game.

One good CB, eg Guehi should be enough to cover and he’s good enough to rotate if Slot wants to do that more this season.

Again, if we sign an overseas player we have to move 2 overseas players from the squad to accommodate - the obvious candidates are Endo, Tsimikas, Darwin, Diaz or Chiesa - Tsimikas works because we already have 2 LBs, but none of the others are defenders, so shifting one of them means we could create a covering issue somewhere else and a lot of those other players are actually useful squadies that can cover multiple positions.

There aren’t many viable home grown options.

So… I’m all for 1 CB - absolutely necessary, but 2 isn’t as essential for me.

Also - I absolutely do not agree with a Klavan/Coates type - that’s a compromise on quality that we don’t need to make. Klavan was good for a team struggling to get into the CL, but a player like that, for me, has no place in a team wanting to win the league or CL. Coates was a waste of space of the type we don’t need to repeat.

Guehi is ideal and if we have to get a second CB, then it would ideally be a younger player.
 
Gomez is fucking pointless even as a 4th choice. He will hardly play not because he’s 4th choice but because he’s fucking injured 98% of the time.

Get in Guehi and a workhorse to step in for a year or two for their last chance at winning anything.
 
Is Isak worth getting at the price being quoted?
Arguably not, but at the very least it helps future proof goals for when Salah drops off/leaves, as well as the obvious Nunez/Diaz/chiesa departure. Guehi future proofs of Konate goes or to replace Virgil. What other CB could come in that's appropriate? Just get some youth CB that has a high ceiling and pray.
 
What’s the point in Ekitike then? Unless we are planning for a massive shift in formation in 26/27 it makes no sense.

We’re gonna get goals, lots of goals with this squad.

I’d be more comfortable with the two CBs, DM slot will trust and maybe Salah’s replacement. £130 million is a lot of money and could stretch that far.
 
Could Lucky and Nallo fill in? Are they training with the 1st team? If not promote them to 1st team may be? There are plenty of CBs out there that are in the Championship who will defiantly come in as 4th choice like Taylor Harwood-Bellis with PL experience but will we have enough money after Isak and Guehi? And is Guehi even possible?
 
Could Lucky and Nallo fill in? Are they training with the 1st team? If not promote them to 1st team may be? There are plenty of CBs out there that are in the Championship who will defiantly come in as 4th choice like Taylor Harwood-Bellis with PL experience but will we have enough money after Isak and Guehi? And is Guehi even possible?
If they didn’t play yesterday then they aren’t good enough at this time.
 
Back
Top Bottom