
Well Salah is not playing worse than Isak and he definitely warrants a spot ahead of him.
Salah being unhappy about being forced out the club was predictable. Slot's response has been a total fucking mess. Horrid man management.
They've both been shit, but one might become not shit and represents an investment in the future, the other is not part of any plans beyond this season. So of course we might humour isak more than Salah. If anyone could be aggrieved about isak, it should be tekkers, not Salah.
Salah has been shit and is also a petulant bitch, but let's not pretend the club hasn't actively engineered this situation.
One was the Premier League Golden Boot, Premier League Top Assist provider, Player of the Year, and Premoer League Champion for the season that ended just seven months ago, and has a contract until the end of next season.
The other has been on hunger strike for three months.
It’s time to accept he doesn’t have Klopp’s man management skills and yes it’s showing. Is it a dealbreaker? We will see.
But that's just a silly point. Were any of them hands down the best player in the league and arguably the world last season in terms of impact?Personally I'd re-sign rush, Kenny, Barnes and Hansen. "Form is temporary" and all that
And yet here he is, barely making an impact on games and barely defending in a game.But that's just a silly point. Were any of them hands down the best player in the league and arguably the world last season in terms of impact?
You make it sound like Salah is 39.
Was it paisley who threw the players title medals in a bin and tell them they mean shit now as they’re in the past and next season is what matters?
He probably misses people saying "Trent can't defend" to hide the fact that he didn't defend.Side note, but I actually think Salah really misses Trents impact, we never really replaced that, and it was very important for Salah. Once Trent was going, we needed to find a way to replace what he did, creatively, and we didn't.
And yet here he is, barely making an impact on games and barely defending in a game.
He's fucked off everything isn't tailored to him any more and his performances match that.
It will ultimately boil down to the outcome though, the club should be handling it overall, Slot's and Salah's personal feelings towards how each have professionally acted shouldn't come into it. We've been here with Ged and Rafa where they fell out with top players who you then knew were out the door and it became their undoing. We know Slot has a stubborn nature, so letting him lead it is where you get comments like this and it just feeds the fall out.I don’t think Slot has done a lot wrong here. He’s been pretty classy bar thay one comment about wondering if the player will admit he made a mistake. Salah attacked him. This was a very mild response.
It’s time to accept he doesn’t have Klopp’s man management skills and yes it’s showing. Is it a dealbreaker? We will see.
We've lost the firepower and endless energy from both full backs. Robbo was so fit that he could cover forward and back endlessly. He also had a very very good connection and understanding with Gini & Mane who were hit go-to players on the left.Side note, but I actually think Salah really misses Trents impact, we never really replaced that, and it was very important for Salah. Once Trent was going, we needed to find a way to replace what he did, creatively, and we didn't.
I think you are making too little of that outburst calling it 'a moment of indiscipline'. He didn't throw a paddy walking off the pitch, that would be a moment of indiscipline, he calculatedly crucified the club & the manager all whilst egotistically lauding himself. If Slot 'hit back' as you call it (and it was a query even if a pointed one) then I think he can be forgiven in comparison to the comments Salah made.I thought that Slot/the club handled Mo's comments fairly well, pointing to his omission from the Inter travelling party as his/their response to Mo. A disciplinary issue, nothing more, nothing less.
So I'm amazed that Slot's hit back at Mo publicly with comments to Seedorf after the Inter match: "Does the player think he's made a mistake as well?" suggesting that for Slot, at least, the issue isn't closed and it's become personal for him too.
On the one hand, you have one of our greatest players of the PL era, who's had seven good to great seasons, and won it all for the club, and was punished for a moment of indiscipline. On the other, a manager who's so full of hubris he's comfortable continuing to play out this drama in the media. I don't get it. Because he won the title last season? Lest it be forgotten, so did Mo. Because he beat Inter? We've been there before, when we beat Villa and Madrid earlier. Some winning streak that was.
Let's be clear, Mo was wrong and he hasn't been playing well and was probably deservedly dropped - but Slot has gotten lucky because in the midst of the outrage at Mo's narcissism, it seems to have been forgotten that Mo's decline can be traced to Slot's system which has arguably failed to draw the best out of a majority of the players in the squad this season. For him to make these comments after Inter, in my opinion, is just classless.
Don't be so ridiculous. Whatever went on at Newcastle (and if I remember correctly they put him to train on his own then stopped him coming altogether - he just refused to return when invited back) has nothing (bar affecting his fitness) to do with who should be selected now he's at LFC.One was the Premier League Golden Boot, Premier League Top Assist provider, Player of the Year, and Premoer League Champion for the season that ended just seven months ago, and has a contract until the end of next season.
The other has been on hunger strike for three months.
I would say the tactics and changing personal are the biggest reason but he’s still still among the biggest impacters even having missed 3 of the last 4 games.And yet here he is, barely making an impact on games and barely defending in a game.
He's fucked off everything isn't tailored to him any more and his performances match that.
Don't get me wrong, there MANY players who deserved to be dropped this season, but few others who are as old as him and no others leaving for 2 months of the season.
He's been a petulant child, and I genuinely couldn't care about what he did last season. That's for the history books.
Is that how come we won the PL last season then? Terrible man management?Man management is the difference between finding 5th with a shit, half dead squad, and struggling in 10th after spending half a billion.
Agreed however if you change the team that results in a monumentally negative way in terms of outcome and the output of the teams best producer and then scapegoat him when others have been as bad or worse and then manage it terribly then it’s not as cut and dry imo.Could be. Either way, it was before my time and a story which says what you did for the team last season means nothing for this season. Players change, teams change and if you can’t adapt then you need to move on.
Hang on ... what ?! That is exactly as he's always played! The issue is he's lost his pace, control and mostly can't go past even a solitary FB any more, never mind when he's being doubled up on. If he can't get into the box any more that's on him because no it's not that he doesn't have support (Szobo, Frimpong, Bradley ... even Gomez was playing too high up the pitch, as I moaned about at the time).I do agree on the first sentence, but I also think a lot of this is tactics and personnel. One big thing that has buggered our RW is that we've played about 7 players at RB as everyone keeps getting injured.
Add to this a completely uninspiring approach when we have the ball, there is nothing being done to get the best out of a player we know is lethal inside the box. He is being limited and isolated on the wing, or having more and more of his cut-inside-and-shoots from outside the box. He needs to be in a system where he's in the box receiving balls when he's making an outside-in run into the box.
I don't like how he's reacted. But I think a lot of his role is down to the 'head coach' and given he has played everyone else in other positions, I am amazed we haven't see Mo tried on the LW, at CF or even as AM.
Hang on ... what ?! That is exactly as he's always played! The issue is he's lost his pace, control and mostly can't go past even a solitary FB any more, never mind when he's being doubled up on. If he can't get into the box any more that's on him because no it's not that he doesn't have support (Szobo, Frimpong, Bradley ... even Gomez was playing too high up the pitch, as I moaned about at the time).
We've tried him centre and it just didn't work for whatever reason. I always thought he'd make a great 10 - but he didn't.
Ok 2 mins later I found these.
Touches last season to now:
![]()
![]()
This season's shot map:
![]()
As suggested - there are more which are in much lower xG zones and outside of the box too.
My overall point being - we aren't playing in a way that is setting him (or frankly any one of our players) for success.
You've misinterpreted what I said. I said the issue isn't so much those around him - it's him. We've all seen it. He can hardly beat a man any more. He certainly can't for pace and he hardly dribbles any more (look at his dribbling stats).Not quite. He would always start wide, but if you were to look at his goal map they come inside the box. I imagine if you looked at his shot map this season, they are outside of the box. It only needs to be a 3-4 yard difference and there is an extra line of players in the way.
Doing some research on the fly. Mo's goals last season:
![]()
I can't find a shot map but i'm sure its out there - I would be there is a lot less on that line between penalty spot and RH post and more towards the outside of the box.
Not saying its a huge shift, but its enough to see a big drop off.
If you truly believe he is playing the same as he always has, and that the tactics around him haven't changed - I admire the lack of detail you watch for in a football game.
You've misinterpreted what I said. I said the issue isn't so much those around him - it's him. We've all seen it. He can hardly beat a man any more. He certainly can't for pace and he hardly dribbles any more (look at his dribbling stats).
All those charts show, that you put up above, is what we all know - that he's shooting from outside, in much lower xG positions, simply because he's not capable of consistently beating players, to enable him to get inside, any more. That's not on his 'support' or our style of play.
Players such as Szobo, Wirtz even Macca and Bradley, can and do find him easily. It's a misnomer to say he's 'isolated'.
I agree that he has lost some of his pace & skill. But if that is obvious to us, why isn't our 'head coach' adapting a system to play to his strengths? I think we're isolating him even more than we did when he was at his peak.
Our 'head coach' is a dud, and he's got zero idea how to get a competent attacking performance out of a team including the likes of fucking Isak, Salah, Wirtz, Szobo, Ekitike etc.
We easily have the best attacking roster in the league. And we're awful.
