• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Coutinho

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you're missing the vitriolic/sarcastic OTT level of some of Ryan's points about him - "He had an horrific game against Bolton", "Lallana scores and creates goals, Coutinho evades opponents on the halfway line". Really?

It's not fair or even remotely constructive.

Should people want more from him? Yes - fair. Should we put up with bollocks comments like the above and not challenge it with clear facts? Well many have, and it's largely been overlooked by those criticising him.
So it's a Ryan thing and the way he expresses himself, not about Coutinho then


Coutinho is in a rich vein of form, however there was a period this season where he was fucking shite. Over hitting passes, wasting possession, etc. It's only the last 4-6 weeks he's become consistently brilliant.

Did I think Coutinho had a poor game against Bolton? No, but he faded dramatically in the second half, and I only noticed him at the end with that shot.
 
As others have pointed out, while he should be capable of 10 a season you'd be surprised at how few manage it.


That's a good point - and also, how often they manage it. Some examples of existing Premier League players, and how many times they've scored 10 or more in a season across all competitions (while playing for a club in the top division in Europe). Italicized, red = recorded while playing in the Premier League.

- Nasri: twice - Arsenal (15), City (11)
- Silva: once - Valencia (10)
- Cazorla: once - Arsenal (12)
- Fabregas: 5 times - Arsenal (13, 19), Barca (15, 14, 13)
- Hazard: 6 times - Lille (10, 12, 22), Chelsea (13, 17, 11 - current season)
- Oscar: twice, Chelsea (12, 11) - currently on 7
- Ozil: thrice, Werder Bremen (11), Real Madrid (10, 10)
- Modric: twice, Dinamo Zagreb (14, 17)
- Ramsey: once, Arsenal (16)
- Mata: 4 times - Valencia (14, 14), Chelsea (12, 20)
- Eriksen: thrice - Ajax (13), Spurs (10, 11 - current season)

Fabregas' record is actually quite interesting. I remember when he was younger, the main criticism of him was that he didn't score enough. Then he exploded in the season Henry left, going from 4 goals to 13 in a season. The next season, hit by injuries, he slumped to 3, only to explode again and hit 19 the following season (despite playing about the same number of games as the season before). He finished with 9 the following season before leaving for Barca.

Also interesting that the ones who do it with an English club often do so while playing for Arsenal or Chelsea.
 
So it's a Ryan thing and the way he expresses himself, not about Coutinho then


Coutinho is in a rich vein of form, however there was a period this season where he was fucking shite. Over hitting passes, wasting possession, etc. It's only the last 4-6 weeks he's become consistently brilliant.

Did I think Coutinho had a poor game against Bolton? No, but he faded dramatically in the second half, and I only noticed him at the end with that shot.

Mate, I can't be arsed with this - you said people are getting defensive about the criticism, as though people are abusing Coutinho and being unfair, well yes, at least one of you are. People know he can improve, pointing it out in the way it's been done throughout this thread has seriously lacked perspective. It's not just been a fair, "he's great isn't he, but if he wants to be World Class he has to...", it's been more a case of dumbing down his quality.
 
Not really. Dreamy is doing cartwheels because Ryan has been handing him his arse for the past 8 years and in one throwaway comment about scoring important goals Dreamy has finally thought he has a chance to point score and posted about 30 times in two pages his glee filled points scoring posts.
Completely ignoring the fact that Ryan, myself and others rate the fuck out of Coutinho but have some questions about his end product.

I dont really give a fuck to continue this anymore though pal. I want Coutinho to be a boss for us and he looks like he could be.
I dont really care what anybody else thinks.

Agree to disagree so. Ryan started the "he doesn't score important goals" debate and said it a few times. If Dreamy had said it and Ryan thought the other way he would have ripped Dreamy to fucking shreds.

I agreed above that people are being too precious. This thread didn't seem like it was supposed to be about comparing players and I hate when people bring up other player's failings to make a point. It's as if being right is more important than a player doing well for us. Modo...I mean Sherman is ridiculously guilty of it. Phillipe is a gem and I'm delighted he signed a contract. If Sterling follows suits we'll have a fearsome front 3 for the foreseeable future with a lot of potential to back it up.
 
The level bias here is nauseating. People here hiding behind claims of being fair and balanced in their critique of Coutinho, while totally neglecting or in some cases protecting some God awful performances by other players.
This is not about being wrong imo, its about knowing when to shut up.

The sad thing is, if Coutinho has a bad game against Everton, they'll be on his case again.

Hahahhaha.
 
Not really. Dreamy is doing cartwheels because Ryan has been handing him his arse for the past 8 years and in one throwaway comment about scoring important goals Dreamy has finally thought he has a chance to point score and posted about 30 times in two pages his glee filled points scoring posts.
Completely ignoring the fact that Ryan, myself and others rate the fuck out of Coutinho but have some questions about his end product.

I dont really give a fuck to continue this anymore though pal. I want Coutinho to be a boss for us and he looks like he could be.
I dont really care what anybody else thinks.
I never said you, Ryan or anyone else didn't praise Him I was merely pointing out Ryan's post was incorrect and as usual he proves he can never admit he got something wrong. And if you want to talk about constant points scoring or hammering home a point have a look at any post I've made about strikers this year and you'll quick fire find a post from Ryan telling me how I wanted Torres for 10m instead of Mario. There must half a dozen of the same post.
Ryan made a point which I said was incorrect, he made his usual 'you are a moran and wrong ' comment. I backed up my point with clear facts. Ryan chooses to ignore it as usual. That's it.
The fact you singled me out just shows you really dislike me more than anything else, which is fair enough but that post was strange in a thread full of similar posts.
But I'll leave you to your opinions.
 
I never said you, Ryan or anyone else didn't praise Him I was merely pointing out Ryan's post was incorrect and as usual he proves he can never admit he got something wrong. And if you want to talk about constant points scoring or hammering home a point have a look at any post I've made about strikers this year and you'll quick fire find a post from Ryan telling me how I wanted Torres for 10m instead of Mario. There must half a dozen of the same post.
Ryan made a point which I said was incorrect, he made his usual 'you are a moran and wrong ' comment. I backed up my point with clear facts. Ryan chooses to ignore it as usual. That's it.
The fact you singled me out just shows you really dislike me more than anything else, which is fair enough but that post was strange in a thread full of similar posts.
But I'll leave you to your opinions.
I dont dislike you at all Pat. I think your ace.
Dont mix football opinion with personal opinion.
 
I never said you, Ryan or anyone else didn't praise Him I was merely pointing out Ryan's post was incorrect and as usual he proves he can never admit he got something wrong. And if you want to talk about constant points scoring or hammering home a point have a look at any post I've made about strikers this year and you'll quick fire find a post from Ryan telling me how I wanted Torres for 10m instead of Mario. There must half a dozen of the same post.
Ryan made a point which I said was incorrect, he made his usual 'you are a moran and wrong ' comment. I backed up my point with clear facts. Ryan chooses to ignore it as usual. That's it.
The fact you singled me out just shows you really dislike me more than anything else, which is fair enough but that post was strange in a thread full of similar posts.
But I'll leave you to your opinions.

You made a fair point DB, a few people have, in response to some of the outlandish claims in this thread and elsewhere, but they haven't been acknowledged either, or they've been ridiculed like yours was.There were some pretty daft claims about what he does and doesn't do, which were pissed on with facts, yet the comments were completely ignored. Quelle Surprise.

People think his critics are being over the top, well yeah, read some of the quoted posts. No one this side of the fence is defending him to the hilt. Like I said, he's a great little player with the potential to be top drawer, but he needs to keep improving and iron out a few issues, the same can be said of most young attackers - that's not the same as what his critics have been saying here. People seem to look at players who play at other clubs, with rose tinted spectacles, while picking the bones out of our own. It does my fucking head in. Even more so when Average Joe's like Allen & Borini have been afforded a disproportionate level of faith, backing and championing.
 
The level bias here is nauseating. People here hiding behind claims of being fair and balanced in their critique of Coutinho, while totally neglecting or in some cases protecting some God awful performances by other players.
This is not about being wrong imo, its about knowing when to shut up.

The sad thing is, if Coutinho has a bad game against Everton, they'll be on his case again.
Isn't it time for you to start saying we need Rafa back?

If you are who people think you are then its wonderful irony that you're banging on about agendas. You were the most agenda driven poster on the fucking site.
 
I really don't know what you're talking about.
The only reason I posted that rant about Coutinho is because I was baffled to see a thread where he's being criticised during a time when he arguably is our most in form player along with Sterling, Lucas, Sakho and possibly Mignolet.

It's true, I've been to this forum before but I'm not who you think I am.
 
B9QLPmFIMAAmuqY.jpg
 
I really don't know what you're talking about.
The only reason I posted that rant about Coutinho is because I was baffled to see a thread where he's being criticised during a time when he arguably is our most in form player along with Sterling, Lucas, Sakho and possibly Mignolet.

It's true, I've been to this forum before but I'm not who you think I am.

Lallana should be here in place of Coutinho. I'm not sure why he's relatively shielded from criticism. Maybe it's because he can't even make the bench.
 
Lallana should be here in place of Coutinho. I'm not sure why he's relatively shielded from criticism. Maybe it's because he can't even make the bench.
By all means start a thread then


People are fucking terrified to start threads on here
 
People are very precious of our players sometimes. It's odd.

Supporters innit? I find it odd that you champion Borini and Balotelli while criticising Gerrard and Coutinho, but until this post I just left it be, 'cos ya know, some people are odd.
 
Supporters innit? I find it odd that you champion Borini and Balotelli while criticising Gerrard and Coutinho, but until this post I just left it be, 'cos ya know, some people are odd.
Don't fret. My support of balo and Borini has long since departed. It's all for the Lulz now
 
Hmmm, quite the melodrama. And God bless Dreamy busting his wee heart out to try and win an argument. I'm almost proud of him.

I'll respond to this properly in a bit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom