It is fairly common on these board that there is heated arguments over the merits of individual players with many posters having polar opposite views.
I often find myself nodding sagely in agreement with the views of some while shaking my head in disbelief at others.
However I am interested to know if the same posters share almost identical opinions on all these divisive players or is it more random depending on the individual player.
Here is a list of players who seem to generate divided opinion. Feel free to add more players that I have missed and try and keep your yes/no based on their footballing contribution/ability and not on their personality
Here goes............
Kuyt -strong yes
Agger -weak yes
Skrtel -weak no
Wilson - yes
Lucas- weak yes
Meireles - strong yes
Cole - no
Ngog- weak no
Carragher - strong yes
Babel - no
Cisse - no
Riise - weak no
I often find myself nodding sagely in agreement with the views of some while shaking my head in disbelief at others.
However I am interested to know if the same posters share almost identical opinions on all these divisive players or is it more random depending on the individual player.
Here is a list of players who seem to generate divided opinion. Feel free to add more players that I have missed and try and keep your yes/no based on their footballing contribution/ability and not on their personality
Here goes............
Kuyt -strong yes
Agger -weak yes
Skrtel -weak no
Wilson - yes
Lucas- weak yes
Meireles - strong yes
Cole - no
Ngog- weak no
Carragher - strong yes
Babel - no
Cisse - no
Riise - weak no